
Assessment Brief:
Subject: Mental Health in Practice
Assessment Task: Critical evaluation of an AI-generated supportive conversation script
– Written critique
Length 2500 words (+/- 10)
Appendix: Screenshot Generative AI script (not included in the word count)
Due date: 06/11/2026 @8pm Melbourne Time
Assessment Task
In this assessment, you will create an AI-generated script of a supportive conversation between a person needing support with a mental health issue and a non-mental health professional (a‘supporter’). You will then critique the effectiveness and appropriateness of the support provided by the supporter.
Please refer to the Instructions for details on how to complete this task.
Instructions
To complete this task, you will:
1. Create prompts for a supportive conversation script using a Generative AI tool
Create a script of a non-mental health professional supporting someone experiencing a
mental health issue. Use the following information to design your prompts. and input these
into your chosen Generative AI tool such as Bard or ChatGPT. You can be as specific as you
like.
Critical Evaluation of Mental Health
Refer to the website below to assist you in creating prompts:
coursera.org – IBM course on Engineering GenAI prompts.
Important note: This means you must write your own prompts and not just input the
information below.
• The script should be 15-20 minutes long (approximately 2500 words).
• The person being supported is experiencing symptoms of depression or anxiety and
indicate they are in crisis.
• The supporter needs to use at least three of the supportive conversation strategies
included in this subject.
• Create a profile for the supporter and person being supported including their name, age,
occupation, any other demographic information you would like to include.
• The supporter should demonstrate supportive conversation skills at a beginner to
intermediate level.
• The supporter should take overstep appropriate boundaries in some way e.g., by trying to
fix the problem for them and not directing the person to additional supports if they are in
crisis.
2. Critique of the supporter’s approach:
Using your knowledge of supportive conversation skills from this subject, critique the
supporter’s ability to effectively put these skills into practice. Support your critique with
references.
Critical Evaluation of Mental Health
• How well did the supporter use supportive conversation strategies?
Use the following questions as a guide:
• What did they do verbally and non-verbally to enact those strategies?
• What errors did they make? What could they improve upon?
• What would you have done differently or adjusted if you were doing the session?
Please include academic and professional sources to support your critique using correct APA
style.
Please format this task as follows:
1. Introduction including an overview of the task and the Generative AI prompts you used
(approximately 400 words)
2. Critique of the supporter’s approach, with support from references (approximately 1350
words)
3. Conclusion including a summary of your findings and learnings (approximately 250 words)
4. Reference list
5. Appendix: Generative AI script (not included in the word count)
Reference
Critical Evaluation of Mental Health



