Civil Rules [LAW] Interpretive Assignment [SOLVED]

Law Essay

Table of Contents

Introduction 3

Discussion 3

Conclusion 7

References 8

Introduction

It has been identified that the conference was purported to develop and settle terms of new international convention- United Nations Convention on the Prevention and Management of Wildland Fires (the “Convention”). The theme of the convention was “The Prevention and Management of Wildland Fires”. The current study will analyze the Bushfire Prevention and Management Act 2019 (Cth) specifically of section 6 and section 7 in light of the case study provided. The Act has been passed with developing some objectives including providing a framework to be used for preventing out of control fires in the wildland areas. Along with this, an attempt has also been taken to develop a protocol for the orderly management of the ecologically sustainable reduction of fuel in the wildlife areas. Another objective was to provide better protection of the wildlife and traditional communities of that area.

Discussion

An act is required to be interpreted based on some ground rules such as its literal rule, golden rules, mischief rules and others (Gluck, 2017). The current study will attempt to apply the provisions of the Act mentioned in order to advise Robyn and Johnnie as they have been charged under section 6 and section 7 of the act. It has been identified in the case study that an annual Sausage Sizzle charity event has been organized by CuttageeCoastcare group in order to raise fund so that they can support research on possible biodynamic means through which the Bitou Bush can be eradicated. Along with this, it was also attempted to develop eco-friendly ways to prevent encroaching of Australian Cheesewood in the dune environment.

There are two incidents that the current study will be focusing on will possibly elicit the charge against Robyn and Johnnie by section 6 and 7. The first incident is where the group members mostly targeted to remove the litters. However, as the fundraising curriculum required the group to cook sausage barbeque required to be placed. The dune environment caused uneven surface making it difficult for placing the barbeque. They have attempted to prevent starting up of fire the grassed site has been levelled with mattocks and shovel. As Johnnie wanted to collapse to fill the rabbit hole with the shovel, it decapacitated a rabbit and led to death. Another incident that elicited the charge under the act was the incident of gas bottle catching fire. Some of the members did not turn off the LPG gas bottle properly. Additionally, Robyn leaned over to pick up the gas bottle it caught fire. Due to this, a nearby patch of Bitou Bush caught alight. As a result, nearby 5 hectors of dune vegetation forming part of the local coastal reserve has been burned. The main issue arose regarding this fire which burnt the entire lettuce crop of a resident of coastal reserve. This resulted from the allowance of Bitou Bush of a valuable windbreak in the garden of that resident.

Advice to Robyn

It can be stated that the act of the whole group caused mainly elicited two incidents against the legal provision of the act. As per the section 6 of “Bushfire Prevention and Management Act 2019 (Cth)”, an individual that is responsible for causing a fire that is lit outside a building, dwelling or any other man-made structure without having permission from the commission would be considered guilty. In a simpler term, it can be stated that this commission is responsible for fulfilling their obligations under the “United Nations Convention on the Prevention and Management of Wildland Fires”. They are provided with the responsibility of promoting and regulating ecologically sustainable management of fauna populations and native vegetation. In order to accomplish the same, the commission will lead to fuel reduction and other practices related to bushfire management practices so that the loss of human life and wildlife can be prevented. As the group required to take permission and discussion about the Bitou Bush fire from the commission, it will be considered as an offence as this led to damage to the human.

The commission here is addressing Commonwealth Bushfire Management Commission that has been established by the current act. The person can be punished by 2 years of imprisonment or a fine up to $200,000. From the scenario of the given case study it can be stated that though Jonnie and Robin did not attempt to burn the lettuce crop of the resident lodging complaint at the police station, their acts are closely related to the damage of the crop. It has been mentioned that as they were eager to get rid of the Bitou Bush they were pleased by causing fire to the nearby Bitou Bush. Robyn and Johnnie observed to focus only on the Bitou Bush being eradicated through the fire. However, they did not show concern about the coastal people residing nearby. Therefore, it can be stated that both individuals were not aware of the consequences of their actions.

In other words, it can be stated that at the time of lifting the gas bottle Robyn had a lit cigarette in her mouth which along with the opened gas bottle caused the fire. It can be stated that Robyn could have been more cautious as she was dealing with a gas bottle which is vulnerable to catch fire. Robyn showed negligence regarding her concern about safely handling the equipment prone to catch fire. Therefore, it can be stated that though the intention was not to set fire on the Bitou Bush, it took place due to the behavioural negligence of Robyn due to which she is being held responsible for the damage caused to the nearby resident. The lettuce crop here can be considered as native vegetation which includes all the plant species whether is of land or sea that have been in Australia since 1788. The lettuce crop is a man-made structure by the resident that raised a complaint about the damage of her crops. Therefore, this act comes under section 6 of the act.

The Bushfire Prevention and Management Bill has been passed in the year 2019 on the 16th of March. The events have taken place on 21 April of 2019. Therefore, it applies to the current contexts.

Advice to Johnnie

Another incident of breaching of the provisions of the act was related to Johnnie’s actions related to levelling the site for placing the barbeque. First of all, the rabbit hole was attempted to be collapsed or filled. At the time of doing so, the shovel sank into the ground causing the death of a rabbit. It can be stated that this was a conscious act of Johnnie who attempted to fill or collapse the rabbi hole as this could cause the death of the rabbit eventually (Mulligan & Staszewski, 2016). Though the act of Johnnie is not directly related to the death of the rabbit, it was a conscious act to cause harm to the rabbit. It has been identified that the convention had developed some objectives among which one of the objectives was to give full protection to the native wildlife and the communities traditionally residing in the wildland areas. The provisions of “Bushfire Prevention and Management Act 2019 (Cth)” define wildlife as all the animal species both inland or sea along with the birds that were present since 1788 in Australia.

The act performed by Johnnie can be considered as the fuel reduction activities that have been developed and designed for reducing potential bushfire commencement or escalation. This is associated with the land clearing activities, controlled burning and back-burning activities. The Act of Johnnie was related to cleaning the land for placing the barbeque.

It has been mentioned in the case study that Jonnie has been charged for breaching section 7 provision of the Act. Section 7 of “Bushfire Prevention and Management Act 2019 (Cth)” enforce that if any action of an individual causes killing, injury or disturbance any wildlife or habitat animal, during any fire prevention activities shall be guilty that is punishable under the act by 2 years of imprisonment or fine up to $500,000. Here, the rabbit is considered a part of the wildlife. Though the action by Johnnie was not directly related to the death of the rabbit, the act of collapsing the hole was intentional for levelling the grassed site. This is surely punishable under this act (Kozel, 2018).

It is required to be mentioned that the event has been organized in the location full consisting of native vegetation and wildlife. It is the core inability of the group to understand the potential impacts of the acts related to this event. Even at the time of conducting the event adequate measures for preventing damage and protecting the native lives could not be taken by the group. The location of the event could have been changed to the other spaces where the potential harms of the event could be minimized to the minimum. It has come under consideration as this has been enforced to be maintained by the act.

It can be stated that Robyn and her team was responsible for taking permission from the commission to conduct the event in the area. Even if there was no incident of damage to the crops or violation of any other provisions, it was an offence not to take permission from the commission. This is directly related to the act performed by Robyn. Robyn can be considered guilty as she was president of the group and taking permission was her responsibility to protect her group from potential charge and preventing any harm to the wildlife and resident of the place chosen by them to conduct the event of fundraising.

This can be discussed under the mischief rule of statutory interpretation. It is required to focus on the fact that Robyn and her team did not take permission from the commission for conducting the event in the mentioned location. The true meaning of provision 6 where it is mentioned that an individual action of whom caused the fire to the native vegetation without taking permission from the commission is guilty. Therefore, it can be stated that though the actions were not intentional as permission was not taken, Robyn will be held guilty. The case of “Smith v Hughes, 1960” can be considered here. It has been held that under the Street Offences Act 1959. Loitering and soliciting in the street due to the purpose of prostitution is considered as a crime. However, it has been claimed by the offenders that they were calling people from the balcony in the streets which are not street related offences. Defendants claimed not to be guilty as they were not in the street. The mischief rule has been applied in this case by the judge. It has been concluded that the defendants were guilty as the main intention of the Act was to prevent prostitutes from harassing people. In this context, the provisions under section 6 are also intended to enforce a standard framework for preventing uncontrolled fire. As the permission was not taken a disregard to this provision has been demonstrated which can be considered as an offence hereunder which Robyn is guilty.

It can be stated that “Bushfire Prevention and Management Act 2019 (Cth)” comes under the Commonwealth government’s Constitutional power. Therefore, the provisions under the act are required to be adhered to while considering any action related to having the potential for harming the natives and the wildlife.

Conclusion

In conclusion, defendants here are Robyn and Johnnie that are charged under section 6 and 7 of the “Bushfire Prevention and Management Act 2019 (Cth)” respectively. The actions performed by Johnnie led the wildlife to be disturbed by killing a rabbit. On the other hand, the act performed by Robyn that was neglecting the potential harm of the event held and smoking of cigarette at the time of lifting the gas bottle. This act has led Robyn to contribute to the burning of the lettuce crop of a resident.

References

Gluck, A. R. (2017). Congress, Statutory Interpretation, and the Failure of Formalism: The CBO Canon and Other Ways That Courts Can Improve on What They Are Already Trying to Do. The University of Chicago Law Review, 177-212.

Kozel, R. J. (2018). Statutory Interpretation, Administrative Deference, and the Law of Stare Decisis. TEx. L. REv.97, 1125.

Smith v Hughes [1960]

Mulligan, L. N., & Staszewski, G. (2016). Civil Rules Interpretive Theory. Minn. L. Rev.101, 2167.

Order Now

Get solved or fresh solution on Civil Rules [LAW] Interpretive Assignment and many more. 24X7 help, plag free solution. Order online now!

Universal Assignment (February 1, 2023) Civil Rules [LAW] Interpretive Assignment [SOLVED]. Retrieved from https://universalassignment.com/civil-rules-law-interpretive-assignment-solved/.
"Civil Rules [LAW] Interpretive Assignment [SOLVED]." Universal Assignment - February 1, 2023, https://universalassignment.com/civil-rules-law-interpretive-assignment-solved/
Universal Assignment July 24, 2022 Civil Rules [LAW] Interpretive Assignment [SOLVED]., viewed February 1, 2023,<https://universalassignment.com/civil-rules-law-interpretive-assignment-solved/>
Universal Assignment - Civil Rules [LAW] Interpretive Assignment [SOLVED]. [Internet]. [Accessed February 1, 2023]. Available from: https://universalassignment.com/civil-rules-law-interpretive-assignment-solved/
"Civil Rules [LAW] Interpretive Assignment [SOLVED]." Universal Assignment - Accessed February 1, 2023. https://universalassignment.com/civil-rules-law-interpretive-assignment-solved/
"Civil Rules [LAW] Interpretive Assignment [SOLVED]." Universal Assignment [Online]. Available: https://universalassignment.com/civil-rules-law-interpretive-assignment-solved/. [Accessed: February 1, 2023]

Please note along with our service, we will provide you with the following deliverables:

Please do not hesitate to put forward any queries regarding the service provision.

We look forward to having you on board with us.

Get 90%* Discount on Assignment Help

Most Frequent Questions & Answers

Universal Assignment Services is the best place to get help in your all kind of assignment help. We have 172+ experts available, who can help you to get HD+ grades. We also provide Free Plag report, Free Revisions,Best Price in the industry guaranteed.

We provide all kinds of assignmednt help, Report writing, Essay Writing, Dissertations, Thesis writing, Research Proposal, Research Report, Home work help, Question Answers help, Case studies, mathematical and Statistical tasks, Website development, Android application, Resume/CV writing, SOP(Statement of Purpose) Writing, Blog/Article, Poster making and so on.

We are available round the clock, 24X7, 365 days. You can appach us to our Whatsapp number +1 (613)778 8542 or email to info@universalassignment.com . We provide Free revision policy, if you need and revisions to be done on the task, we will do the same for you as soon as possible.

We provide services mainly to all major institutes and Universities in Australia, Canada, China, Malaysia, India, South Africa, New Zealand, Singapore, the United Arab Emirates, the United Kingdom, and the United States.

We provide lucrative discounts from 28% to 70% as per the wordcount, Technicality, Deadline and the number of your previous assignments done with us.

After your assignment request our team will check and update you the best suitable service for you alongwith the charges for the task. After confirmation and payment team will start the work and provide the task as per the deadline.

Yes, we will provide Plagirism free task and a free turnitin report along with the task without any extra cost.

No, if the main requirement is same, you don’t have to pay any additional amount. But it there is a additional requirement, then you have to pay the balance amount in order to get the revised solution.

The Fees are as minimum as $10 per page(1 page=250 words) and in case of a big task, we provide huge discounts.

We accept all the major Credit and Debit Cards for the payment. We do accept Paypal also.

Popular Assignments

Question 10 – REPORTS

Complete the table below, by listing three types of financial reports that are produced in your workplace. Type of Report Content of Report Frequently of Report                  

Read More »

Question 9 – BUSINESS RECORDS

Work through the following table and indicate whether each record should be kept or destroyed. Detail the reason for your answer and how long the record should be kept (for example, legislation requirement – retain for five years). Record Keep – Yes or No Reasons Suppliers Invoices     Employee

Read More »

Question 6 – BUSINESS ACTIVITY STATEMENT

Using the following information, complete the Business Activity Statement, you may need to refer to the ATO website to help you complete. Download and complete the Business Activity Statement (BAS). It can be found separately on the course page.

Read More »

Question No 5 – BREAKEVEN ANALYSIS & MOVING

AVERAGE Activity 5.1 – Break-even Answers A. B.   Manage 8 Buildings Manage 10 Buildings Manage 15 Buildings Manage 20 Buildings Manage 25 Buildings Income           Less Variable Costs           Less Fixed Costs           Total Cost    

Read More »

Question 3 – Depreciation

You are the Licensee-In-Charge of Hope & Murphy Real Estate and wish to purchase computers for your new office in the CBD. Using the information below: Office fit out                      $120,000 Assets effective Life          4 years Purchase Date                  1st July STRAIGHT-LINE METHOD CALCULATION Years 1 to 4 – JOURNAL ENTRIES DEPRECIATION                                               

Read More »

Question 1 – PROFIT & LOSS AND BALANCE SHEET

Please note: Editing has been restricted in this document. From the information provided below, complete the following table: Account Name Classification Profit & Loss or Balance Sheet Amount Pay Superannuation Expense Profit & Loss $117,325 Pay Mobile Phone     $7,500 Pay Office Rent     $65,000 Land & Buildings

Read More »

Case Study – WORLDUCATION

Worlducation is a social startup that manufactures tablet computers for primary school students. They not only focus on the hardware, but they also have a competitive team creating software, content and activities to better engage and educate the students. Worlducation aims to change the way children learn at school by

Read More »

BSBOPS505 Manage Organisational Customer Service

BSBOPS505 MANAGE ORGANISATIONAL CUSTOMER SERVICE STUDENTASSESSMENT TASKS QIBA Pty Ltd | CRICOS Provider Code: 01515J | RTO Code: 5304 | ABN: 35 071 667 108  Student Assessment TasksBSBOPS505 Manage Organisational Customer Service     BSBOPS505 Contents Introduction  4 Assessment Task 1: Knowledge questions  5 Assessment Task 1: Checklist 9 Assessment Task 2:

Read More »

BSBOPS505 MANAGE ORGANISATIONAL CUSTOMER SERVICE

BSBOPS505 MANAGE ORGANISATIONAL CUSTOMER SERVICE STUDENT VERSION PROJECT PORTFOLIO Contents Student declaration. 3 Section 1: Establish customer service requirements. 4 Section 2: Deliver quality customer service. 9 Section 3: Monitor and assess customer service. 13 STUDENT PROJECT PORTFOLIO COVER SHEET Student declaration This declaration must be completed in full by

Read More »

GBL Final Take Home Exam

The Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) was meant to be a ground-breaking new agreement by placing 12 economies under a common set of economic norms and regulations. After the US withdrew from the TPP, the remaining 11 signatories continued talks and which led to the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans Pacific

Read More »

PORTFOLIO ASSESSMENT 3

You will be creating a Portfolio record specifically focused on mental health assessments and pharmacological interventions. This is designed to assist in the development of theoretical and clinical skills in mental health, with a direct connection to your clinical practice as a registered student nurse. The evidence record provides you with the opportunity to showcase your learning

Read More »

NRSG375 Clinical Leadership

Assessment Task 3: Written assignment (45%) Discuss and analyse in more detail 2 of the discussion posts that you submitted for assessment task (AT) 2 and use contemporary literature for support. For the 2 posts that you choose, you are to discuss and analyse professional leadership in nursing in further

Read More »

Portfolio record specifically focused on mental health assessments

PORTFOLIO ASSESSMENT 3 You will be creating a Portfolio record specifically focused on mental health assessments and pharmacological interventions. This is designed to assist in the development of theoretical and clinical skills in mental health, with a direct connection to your clinical practice as a registered student nurse. The evidence record provides you with the opportunity to

Read More »

The aetiology of mrs simpsons pain Assignment Help

Length: 1800 words Group Assessment: No Submission method options: EASTS (online) TASK back to top This assessment task requires you to analyse the case study provided below.  In the case study,  a patient is experiencing a range of health challenges. You are required to read the case study carefully and complete the following

Read More »

The Dangers of a Single Story Assignment Help

Narrative Essay Instructions Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s TED Talk titled “The Dangers of a Single Story” recounts instances where one perspective can lead to assumptions, conclusions, and/or decisions that may incomplete or lead to misunderstandings (e.g., think about the story of Fide or how Adichie’s roommate was shocked to learn how

Read More »

LAW1101 21F – Fundamentals of Law

LAW1101 21F – Fundamentals of Law Assignment 1:  Legislative interpretation Due date: Wednesday, November 10, 2021 at 3:00pm Instructions: You are to read two excerpts from legislation and then answer questions about each of them.  The questions are weighted differently and the marks for each question are included.  There are

Read More »

A Work Based Quality Improvement Project

Project Title: Impact of educational intervention on nurses knowledge of hand hygiene in aged care setting: A Work Based Quality Improvement Project Executive Summary: (100- 150 words) Background: Hand hygiene is one of the most important strategies for preventing infections in healthcare settings and healthcare-associated infections, which affect hundreds of

Read More »

Community Health and Development

Part A :  Assessment event 3(a) details Assessment Task 3(a): Apply a problem-solving approach to a social issue in your local community by using the Community Health and Development (2017b) 10-point process. Word count: 2000 Weighting: 35% It is recommended that you: Criteria Fail <17.5 Pass 18- Credit 20 – 22 Distinction 23– 25 High Distinction 

Read More »

RE-AWAKENING HEALTH SYSTEMS

In this assignment, you are asked to pick ONE of the following case studies and answer a series of questions about the particular health situation that is described. In each case study, you are asked to examine the significance of the issue for Australia, explore the condition from a very broad policy

Read More »

FINAL EXAM – SPRING SESSION Building Law

FINAL EXAM – SPRING SESSION 2021 School of Law EXAM INSTRUCTIONS Read all the information below and follow any instructions carefully before proceeding. Clearly indicate which question you are answering.   UNIT NAME: Building Law UNIT NUMBER: 200292 NUMBER OF QUESTIONS: 4 VALUE OF QUESTIONS: Question 1 (10 marks) Question

Read More »

MGMT8055 Brief Case Writeup Bauing Construction Holding Group

Why do you think Bauing Indonesia was so successful? Suggestions government, cost, and competitive Main proof-points The first factor behind this decision was increasing competition in the building and decoration industry in China. In 2016, most public companies in this industry in China experienced decreasing gross margins due to increased

Read More »

MGMT8055 Case Writeup Xiaomi

After recognising numerous global opportunities, Xiaomi in Beijing charted its overseas market strategy in 2013. However, opportunities came with challenges, and during the internationalization process, Xiaomi encountered many problems. After three years of hard work, Xiaomi had gained more experience than profits. Compared with Xiaomi’s domestic success, Xiaomi’s internationalization strategy

Read More »

LNG11120 Developing Intercultural Competence in the Workplace

Edinburgh Napier University Academic Year 2021-22 Trimester 1 Assessment Brief 1.  Module number   LNG11120 2.  Module title   Developing Intercultural Competence in the Workplace 3.  Module leader   4.  Assessment Coursework 1: Group report – an ‘intercultural training’ plan (see Section 10 below for more details) 5.  Weighting  

Read More »

Knowledge, Individual, and Society

Essay 1 Assignment To be submitted via Turnitin on LMS. Assignment: Write a 1,200 word (not including references or footnotes) essay answering ONE of the following questions: 1) What is the Gettier problem and can we solve it? Address this question by carefully explaining and evaluating 1-2 responses to the

Read More »

9014 NPD New Product Design

Summary In the 2000-word written report, students are required to develop some specific aspects of the initial three phases of a new product (service or idea) development process. Students are expected to apply the relevant design thinking tools and ideas in this assessment. Referencing is Australian Harvard (AGPS) and outlined

Read More »

Can't Find Your Assignment?

Open chat
1
Free Assistance
Universal Assignment
Hello 👋
How can we help you?