Assignment 1: Simulating dollar cost averaging

Assignment 1: Simulating dollar cost averaging

1         Introduction

In this report we will compare the lump sum and Dollar Cost Averaging strategies by simulating and boot- strapping the next 12 month period based on the historic monthly stock return data of Australia from MSCI starting in 1969. This will give us further insight in which method our client should use to invest her 150000 euro. The comparison will be made by calculating the annualized holding period return (AHPR) for both strategies. We will also compare our findings with the research of William and Bacon (1993).

2         Monte Carlo Simulation

A Monte Carlo simulation predicts a set of outcomes based on an estimated range of values versus a set of fixed input values (IBM cloud education, 2020). In our simulation we assume the following: monthly returns are normally distributed and the risk-free rate is 0 percent. The parameters for the distribution are estimated and then finally a random number generator is used to generate data according to the presumed distribution. It recalculates the results over and over, each time using a different set of random numbers between the minimum and maximum values. In our case these are based on the historic MSCI data of Australia. In a Monte Carlo experiment, this exercise can be repeated thousands of times to produce a large number of likely outcomes.

2.1         Lump sum

A lump sum investing strategy entails that you invest your entire sum at one given moment in time (Muller, 2021). We replicated this by creating a simulation function. This function uses the mean and standard deviation of our historic monthly stock returns from MSCI and simulates this over a twelve month horizon. It uses this input to generate a random number based upon these parameters and calculates the wealth of given period based upon the wealth of the previous period multiplied by this randomly generated number. We replicated this function 10000 times in order to make our simulation more precise.

Table 1: Monte Carlo Simulation – Lump sum: Descriptive Statistics

 MeanMedianStandard DeviationCI Lower BoundCI Upper Bound
Jan/21150000.0150000.00.00150000.0150000.0
Feb/21151355.7151339.27984.38135825.4167109.0
Mar/21152858.7152600.511520.69130695.3176216.8
Apr/21154352.8153731.814241.04128021.6183856.0
May/21155699.9154972.916580.13125316.2190665.8
Jun/21157262.8156234.818770.71123385.8196397.2
Jul/21158794.7157777.520588.86121263.9201807.7
Aug/21160362.4159099.522475.52120083.5208301.2
Sep/21161930.4160702.224152.98118358.4212646.3
Oct/21163413.0162097.725805.90117791.9218719.7
Nov/21164944.7163338.327413.34117672.9224185.6
Dec/21166357.0164219.429084.03116244.0229846.1
Jan/22167898.5165217.530816.61115462.0234504.8

Note:        This table summarizes the descriptive statistics regarding our Monte Carlo Simu- lation where we used the lump sum over a one year horizon.

In Table 1 we show the descriptive statistics of our simulation of the lump sum strategy with 10000 iterations. We calculated the mean, median, standard deviation and the 95 percent confidence interval for the different wealth levels. To determine the end wealth, we look at the December 2021, as this is the twelfth month of the year.

2.2         Dollar Cost Averaging

Dollar Cost Averaging (DCA) is a strategy where an investor invests a total sum of money in small increments over time instead of all at once (Muller, 2021). Investing your money at regular intervals such as weekly, monthly, or quarterly allows the investor to mitigate the risk of buying in at an inflated price. This function uses the mean and standard deviation of our historic monthly stock returns from MSCI and simulates this over a 12 month horizon. It uses this input to generate a random number based upon these parameters and calculates the wealth of given period based upon the starting wealth, which is 12500 euro. Then it adds an additional 12500 and multiplies this sum with the randomly generated number. We replicated this function 10000 times in order to make our simulation more precise.

Table 2: Monte Carlo Simulation – Dollar Cost Averaging: Descriptive Statistics

 MeanMedianStandard DeviationCI Lower BoundCI Upper Bound
Jan/2112500.0012500.000.0012500.0012500.00
Feb/2125235.3725243.211330.2822555.2523519.61
Mar/2138102.5938056.452415.6633373.9035022.93
Apr/2151063.1951015.473619.5744180.3746441.49
May/2164191.2564025.674947.8154955.1257938.23
Jun/2177333.6977062.976438.7265593.0169275.31
Jul/2190594.9290213.198095.5675778.4980447.96
Aug/21104055.71103545.859979.1385936.0091613.31
Sep/21117589.86117026.1111796.6395918.93102770.64
Oct/21131224.89130548.9613852.67105608.27114072.82
Nov/21145122.68144285.5116015.87116390.84124949.34
Dec/21159037.46158004.3418302.89126066.42135908.19
Jan/22173109.32171829.6820513.74136145.75147563.22

Note:        This table summarizes the descriptive statistics regarding our Monte Carlo Simula- tion where we used Dollar Cost Averaging over a one year horizon.

In Table 2 we show the descriptive statistics of our simulation of the Dollar Cost Averaging strategy with 10000 iterations. We calculated the mean, median, standard deviation and the 95 percent confidence interval for the different wealth levels. To determine the end wealth, we look at the December 2021, as this is the twelfth month of the year.

2.3  Lump sum vs Dollar Cost Averaging

We can compare the two strategies based on two different statistics, the mean and the median. We opted for the median, as this is unaffected by extreme outliers and allows us to draw more accurate conclusions. First of we plotted the two functions in order to see which one has the higher median in the twelfth month.

It is difficult to visually see the difference between the two median levels, as the two graphs follow a different trajectory. This is due to the fact that the Dollar Cost Averaging strategy adds 12500 every month. However, in Table 1 and Table 2 we can see that the medians in the twelfth month are 164219.40 euro and 158004.34 euro respectively. This shows us that the median of the lump sum strategy is higher than that of the Dollar Cost Averaging strategy. In order to compare our results with the research of Williams and Bacon (1993), we calculate the annualized holding period return (AHPR).

Notes: This figure plots Monte Carlo Simulations for the lump sum and Dollar Cost Averaging strategies.

𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴ℎ

− 1

𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴 =  𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴ℎ

The AHPR for the lump sum strategyis 9.48% and 5.34% for the Dollar Cost Averaging strategy. The AHPR for the lump sum strategy is 4.14% higher. These findings are consistent with the conclusions of Williams and Bacon (1993), who stated that “the sooner the entire endowment is fully invested in the market, the higher the realized return.”

3         Bootstrap

We control our findings with the bootstrap method. Instead of generating random observations from a theo- retical distribution, a bootstrap generates observations from the empirical distribution by drawing randomly from the sample (Annaert, 2021). Bootstrap uses the empirical distribution to simulate. It is assumes that one-period returns are identically and independently distributed. This implies that the order in which we observed the actual returns was coincidental. Any other ranking would have been possible. If there are T observations in a sample, each of these T outcomes could have been observed for any given period. This means that there are T H equally likely H – period return paths that could have occurred. In principle, these paths can be used to derive the distribution of all statistics an investor would need to make investment decisions. This is another way to generate the random returns. We take random values from the historical sample rather than assuming a normal distribution,. The sample() function does this for us.

3.1         Lump sum

We used the mean and standard deviation of our historic monthly stock returns from MSCI and bootstrapped this over a twelve month horizon. Instead of generating a random number, the bootstrap method retrieves a random number from our sample. It calculates the wealth of given period based upon the wealth of the previous period multiplied by this randomly selected return. We replicated this function 10000 times in order to make our simulation more precise.

Table 3: Bootstrapping – Lump sum: Descriptive Statistics

 MeanMedianStandard DeviationCI Lower BoundCI Upper Bound
Jan/21150000.0150000.00.00150000.0150000.0
Feb/21150159.9148924.010508.14133287.0178976.7
Mar/21151652.4150768.215204.35124042.1185588.7
Apr/21153710.2152840.518510.60119834.4192183.8
May/21155888.0155091.321127.30116307.4199651.3
Jun/21157949.6157325.923323.88113217.9205362.1
Jul/21159825.1159155.124978.71110417.1211005.6
Aug/21161443.9160667.026288.54109359.1215722.4
Sep/21162938.5162233.427338.55108350.6219884.9
Oct/21164130.8163276.728230.27108542.5222802.2
Nov/21165257.7164304.229082.30108712.5226078.4
Dec/21166450.7165207.530020.30108539.1229534.0
Jan/22167887.4166786.931025.75108549.4232455.6

Note:       This table summarizes the descriptive statistics regarding our bootstrap where we used the lump sum over a one year horizon.

In Table 3 we show the descriptive statistics of our bootstrap of the lump sum strategy with 10000 iterations. We calculated the mean, median, standard deviation and the 95 percent confidence interval for the different wealth levels. To determine the end wealth, we look at the December 2021, as this is the twelfth month of the year.

3.2         Dollar Cost Averaging

We used the mean and standard deviation of our historic monthly stock returns from MSCI and bootstrapped this over a 12 month horizon. It uses this sample to randomly select a return and calculates the wealth of given period based upon the starting wealth, which is 12500 euro. Then it adds an additional 12500 and multiplies this sum with the randomly selected number. We replicated this function 10000 times in order to make our bootstrap more precise.

Table 4: Monte Carlo Simulation – Dollar Cost Averaging: Descriptive Statistics

 MeanMedianStandard DeviationCI Lower BoundCI Upper Bound
Jan/2112500.0012500.000.0012500.0012500.00
Feb/2125005.7324820.661773.3221400.8629829.45
Mar/2137843.4837697.623237.3531668.8844815.56
Apr/2151083.4051011.894788.9642006.4760793.33
May/2164535.8664570.636312.0252220.5776919.39
Jun/2178122.7778199.747781.2062931.3793156.47
Jul/2191795.4891851.229054.8973806.87109298.41
Aug/21105294.45105463.8510210.9785118.67125115.71
Sep/21118889.31118846.6411346.1296616.37141192.44
Oct/21132447.22132498.4812521.77108012.90157215.37
Nov/21146051.33146049.6513867.54118760.82173587.49
Dec/21159614.88159668.2515287.57129097.67189496.78
Jan/22173469.93173694.6716962.74138618.27206750.79

Note:        This table summarizes the descriptive statistics regarding our bootstrap where we used Dollar Cost Averaging over a one year horizon.

In Table 4 we show the descriptive statistics of our bootstrap of the Dollar Cost Averaging strategy with 10000 iterations. We calculated the mean, median, standard deviation and the 95 percent confidence interval for the different wealth levels. To determine the end wealth, we look at the December 2021, as this is the twelfth month of the year.

3.3         Lump sum vs Dollar Cost Averaging

As previously mentioned, we compare the two strategies based upon their median. We plotted the bootstrap of both strategies to visually see the difference in medians.

However, in Table 3 and Table 4 we can see that the medians in the twelfth month are 165207.55 euro and 159668.25 euro respectively. This shows us that the median of the lump sum strategy is higher than that of the Dollar Cost Averaging strategy. In order to compare our results with the research of Williams and Bacon (1993), we calculate the annualized holding period return (AHPR).

𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴ℎ

− 1

𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴 =  𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴ℎ

Text Box: WealthText Box: 120000Text Box: 160000 200000Text Box: WealthText Box: 50000Text Box: 1500002021.0        2021.2        2021.4         2021.6        2021.8         2022.0                       2021.0         2021.2        2021.4         2021.6        2021.8                   2022.0

Time                                                                                                                            Time

Figure 2: Plot Monte Carlo Simulations

Notes: This figure plots the bootstraps for the lump sum and Dollar Cost Averaging strategies.

The AHPR for the lump sum strategy is 10.14% and 6.45% for the Dollar Cost Averaging strategy. The AHPR for the lump sum strategy is 3.69% higher. These findings align with our previous results of the Monte Carlo simulations. Furthermore, these results are once more consistent with the conclusions of the research of Williams and Bacon (1993).

4         Conclusion

Our results show that the annualized holding period returns for both the Monte Carlo simulation as the bootstrap method are higher for the lump sum method. These results were computed based upon a the sample of historic monthly stock return data of Australia from MSCI starting in 1969. This inclines us to state that the lump sum method outperforms the Dollar Cost Averaging method. Furthermore, these results are consistent with the findings of Williams and Bacon (1993). Therefore we would advice our client to invest her capital using the lump sum strategy.

5         References

Annaert, J. (2021) Quantitative Methods in Finance

IBM cloud education (2020). Monte Carlo Simulation Retrieved from https://www.ibm.com/cloud/learn/ monte- carlo-simulation

Muller (2021). Dollar Cost Averaging vs Lum Sum which is better from https://www.moneyunder30.com/ dollar- cost-averaging-vs-lump-sum-investing

Williams, R., Bacon, P. (1993). Citation Lum Sum Beats Dollar Cost Averaging. Journal of Financial Planning

Order Now

Get expert help for Case study 2 — Mary Azacca Assignment and many more. 100% safe, Plag free, 24X7 support, Order Online Now!

No Fields Found.
Universal Assignment (February 29, 2024) Assignment 1: Simulating dollar cost averaging. Retrieved from https://universalassignment.com/assignment-1-simulating-dollar-cost-averaging/.
"Assignment 1: Simulating dollar cost averaging." Universal Assignment - February 29, 2024, https://universalassignment.com/assignment-1-simulating-dollar-cost-averaging/
Universal Assignment July 10, 2022 Assignment 1: Simulating dollar cost averaging., viewed February 29, 2024,<https://universalassignment.com/assignment-1-simulating-dollar-cost-averaging/>
Universal Assignment - Assignment 1: Simulating dollar cost averaging. [Internet]. [Accessed February 29, 2024]. Available from: https://universalassignment.com/assignment-1-simulating-dollar-cost-averaging/
"Assignment 1: Simulating dollar cost averaging." Universal Assignment - Accessed February 29, 2024. https://universalassignment.com/assignment-1-simulating-dollar-cost-averaging/
"Assignment 1: Simulating dollar cost averaging." Universal Assignment [Online]. Available: https://universalassignment.com/assignment-1-simulating-dollar-cost-averaging/. [Accessed: February 29, 2024]

Please note along with our service, we will provide you with the following deliverables:

Please do not hesitate to put forward any queries regarding the service provision.

We look forward to having you on board with us.

Categories

Get 90%* Discount on Assignment Help

Most Frequent Questions & Answers

Universal Assignment Services is the best place to get help in your all kind of assignment help. We have 172+ experts available, who can help you to get HD+ grades. We also provide Free Plag report, Free Revisions,Best Price in the industry guaranteed.

We provide all kinds of assignmednt help, Report writing, Essay Writing, Dissertations, Thesis writing, Research Proposal, Research Report, Home work help, Question Answers help, Case studies, mathematical and Statistical tasks, Website development, Android application, Resume/CV writing, SOP(Statement of Purpose) Writing, Blog/Article, Poster making and so on.

We are available round the clock, 24X7, 365 days. You can appach us to our Whatsapp number +1 (613)778 8542 or email to info@universalassignment.com . We provide Free revision policy, if you need and revisions to be done on the task, we will do the same for you as soon as possible.

We provide services mainly to all major institutes and Universities in Australia, Canada, China, Malaysia, India, South Africa, New Zealand, Singapore, the United Arab Emirates, the United Kingdom, and the United States.

We provide lucrative discounts from 28% to 70% as per the wordcount, Technicality, Deadline and the number of your previous assignments done with us.

After your assignment request our team will check and update you the best suitable service for you alongwith the charges for the task. After confirmation and payment team will start the work and provide the task as per the deadline.

Yes, we will provide Plagirism free task and a free turnitin report along with the task without any extra cost.

No, if the main requirement is same, you don’t have to pay any additional amount. But it there is a additional requirement, then you have to pay the balance amount in order to get the revised solution.

The Fees are as minimum as $10 per page(1 page=250 words) and in case of a big task, we provide huge discounts.

We accept all the major Credit and Debit Cards for the payment. We do accept Paypal also.

Popular Assignments

ORGANISATIONAL STRATEGY PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT ASSIGNMENT

POSTGRADUATE DIPLOMA IN BUSINESS MANAGEMENT ORGANISATIONAL STRATEGY PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT ASSIGNMENT NOTE: At postgraduate level, you are expected to substantiate your answers with evidence from independent research. INTRODUCTION TO THE ASSIGNMENT • This assignment consists of FOUR compulsory questions. Please answer all of them. • When you answer, preferably use

Read More »

Solution: Scenario 1, Mirror therapy in patients post stroke

Title: Scenario 1, Mirror therapy in patients post stroke Part 1 : Summary Ramachandran and colleagues developed mirror therapy to treat amputees’ agony from phantom limbs. Patients were able to feel their amputated limb without experiencing any pain by presenting them a mirror image of their healthy arm. Since then,

Read More »

Solution: Exploring the Dominance of Silence

Slide 1: Title – Exploring the Dominance of Silence The title, “Exploring the Dominance of Silence,” sets the stage for a deep dive into the portrayal of silence in Philip K. Dick’s “Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?” Our presentation will dissect the literary techniques used by the author to

Read More »

Solution: Assessment: Critical Reflection S2 2023

The policies that hampered the cultural survival of Indigenous groups have a major effect on their health (Coffin, 2007). Cultural isolation can cause an identity crisis and a sense of loss, which can exacerbate mental health problems. Indigenous people have greater rates of chronic illness and impairment due to historical

Read More »

Solution: The Market – Product and Competition Analysis

Section 1: The Market – Product and Competition Analysis Industry and Competition Analysis: The baking mix market is very competitive, but My Better Batch is entering it anyhow. The prepackaged baking mixes sold in this market allow busy people to have bakery-quality products on the table quickly without sacrificing quality

Read More »

Solution: PDCA model for Riot

Student Name: Student ID: University Name: Date: Learning Outcome 1: Engage actively in recognizing a new product/service for Riot and detect the vital tasks required for its effective growth. In this comprehensive learning outcome, Riot’s progress towards innovation superiority is characterized by a deliberate scheme that draws on components from

Read More »

Solution: EDEN 100 – ASSIGNMENT 1

Part 1: Reflections on the Register Variables Use the questions in Column 1 and analyse the sample oral interactions provided under the assessment tile. The transcript for Viv’s conversation is provided on pages 4-5. Probe Questions  Link to readings and theory Interaction 1 Interaction 2 PART 1 – ANALYSING THE

Read More »

Solution: TCP/IP Questions

Table of Contents Question 1. 1 1. IPSec datagram protocol 1 2. Source and destination IP addresses in original IP datagram.. 1 3. Source and destination IP addresses in new IP header 2 4. Protocol number in the protocol field of the new IP header 2 5. Information and Bob.

Read More »

Solution: Fundamentals of Employment Assistance Program and Counselling

ASSESSMENT 3 Subject: Fundamentals of Employment Assistance Program and Counselling Case study Question 1 a)     Major Issues for Theo that could be addressed in counselling: b)    Issues to Address First in Short-Term Counselling:             The cognitive processes of memory, focus, and decision-making are all impacted by insufficient sleep. Such cognitive

Read More »

Solution: EQUITY AND INCLUSION IN EARLY CHILDHOOD IN AUSTRALIA

Written Policy Recommendation Name: Student Number: Email: Date: Introduction: The early years of a child’s life are important for their holistic development, making early childhood education a foundation for their future accomplishments. Nevertheless, guaranteeing equality and inclusion in early childhood education stays a major problem in our society. This policy

Read More »

Solution: Report Health Issue

Table of Contents Executive Summary                                                                                                   3 Introduction                                                                                                                5 Examination of the Chosen Health Issue in the Context of Lambeth                        5 Application of Health Inequality Framework and Analysis of Determinants: Psychotropic Drug Use in Lambeth                                                                           6 Exploration and Discussion of Strategies to Manage Psychotropic Drug Use in Lambeth                                                                                                                        7 Conclusion                                                                                                                  8

Read More »

Solution: Section III: Marketing

Section III: Marketing Channels for Advertising: Understanding Who Makes Baking Product Purchase Decisions is Crucial for My Better Batch’s Business Success (Sampson et al, 2017). Home bakers may make up a disproportionate share of the decision-makers in the UK. As a result, My Better Batch has to target people, especially

Read More »

Solution: Analytics Project Project Management Plan

Analytics Project Project Management Plan Date: 22-10-2023 Author: Name Here Version: 2.0 Project Management Plan (PMP) This project management plan will outline the strategies and plans used to manage ‘analytics project’ for the Style-Hub organization. It will include the tasks such as project governance, management, planning, budget and controlling. It

Read More »

Solution: Report Health Issue

Table of Contents Executive Summary                                                                                                   3 Introduction                                                                                                                5 Examination of the Chosen Health Issue in the Context of Lambeth                        5 Application of Health Inequality Framework and Analysis of Determinants: Psychotropic Drug Use in Lambeth                                                                           6 Exploration and Discussion of Strategies to Manage Psychotropic Drug Use in Lambeth                                                                                                                        7 Conclusion                                                                                                                  8

Read More »

Solution: Mirror therapy in patients post stroke

Title: Scenario 1, Mirror therapy in patients post stroke Part 1 : Summary Ramachandran and colleagues developed mirror therapy to treat amputees’ agony from phantom limbs. Patients were able to feel their amputated limb without experiencing any pain by presenting them a mirror image of their healthy arm. Since then,

Read More »

Solution: Case Study – HR Activities

Cover Page Case Study – HR Activities title of assessment unit code unit name semester and year assignment title student name student number tutor name and word count Executive Summary The research suggests two main HR initiatives to help Actualise Health deal with its workforce issues: acquiring and developing talent,

Read More »

Solution: Building a Foundation for Equity and Inclusion

Script – Slide 1: Title and Introduction Greetings, everyone. My name is…, and I would like to discuss a vital concern in early childhood education – equality and inclusion. At present, I’m going to explain why this matter is so important and what research and guidelines indicate about it. Slide

Read More »

Solution: EQUITY AND INCLUSION IN EARLY CHILDHOOD IN AUSTRALIA

Written Policy Recommendation Name: Student Number: Email: Date: Introduction: The early years of a child’s life are important for their holistic development, making early childhood education a foundation for their future accomplishments. Nevertheless, guaranteeing equality and inclusion in early childhood education stays a major problem in our society. This policy

Read More »

Expression of Interest (EOI)

The focus of this Expression of Interest is to demonstrate why you are a good fit for the selected project based on your learning in IKC101.Context:You are submitting an Expression of Interest (EOI) to lead a project connected to the organisation you have chosen. You are required to explain your

Read More »

COM10007 Professional Communication Practice

Assignment 3: PresentationWord/time limit: Five minutes (+/- 10%)Weighting: 15% (Presentation + reference list)Assignment detailsFor this assignment, you are required to consider those who work in the following sectors and describe the key responsibilities of a professional communicator in a particular context—including types of audiences, key messages and delivery modes. You

Read More »

ELT2014 Special Educational Needs and Disabilities

ELT 2014 Assessment 1 – Case Study Module code ELT2014 Module title Special Educational Needs and Disabilities Submission date, time 27/2/24 @ 5pm: Group Presentation slides for part (a) uploaded to TurnItIn 28/2/24 : Group Presentations in class for part (a) – ALL MUST ATTEND 22/3/24 @ 9pm: Suggested deadline

Read More »

Applied Pathobiology Assessment 2 – case study

This assessment covers 30% of the marks for this module. Instructions   Case 1 Vivienne A. (mother) and Isabel A. (daughter) go to the GP for prolonged fatigue in the last four months. Vivienne is a retired 74-year-old teacher, who reports fatigue, tingling and numbness in her hands and feet,

Read More »

Assignment Legislative Framework for Governance

It’s now time to complete your assessment. At Level 5, you must demonstrate that you can follow academic writing standards, including checking your writing for spelling and grammar, referencing using Harvard referencing (or similar) guidelines and utilising critical analysis skills. If you are unsure about these, speak to your Advanced

Read More »

BIK0028/BIH2014 Tips for Individual report assessment

Guidance document: Tips for Individual report assessment BIK0028/BIH2014 Individual report Assessment Assessment brand of your choice. rarity, extraordinariness and a high degree of non-functional associations” (Heine, 2012, p.62). Your work should include the following •       A brief introduction to the selected brand characteristics etc.) •       Your analysis of consumers’ behaviour

Read More »

Can't Find Your Assignment?

Open chat
1
Free Assistance
Universal Assignment
Hello 👋
How can we help you?