BUSINESS AND CORPORATE LAW Case study Questions Assignment Solved

Running Head: Case Study


Assessment 2 Case Study”

Table of Contents

Question 1 2

Question 2 3

Question 3 4

Question 4 5

Question 5 6

References 8

Question 1

Issue: The issue within the case study relates to whether Malcolm has any contractual obligations towards Linda and Cynthia regarding selling the sports car.

Rule: Contract law is governed by provisions contained within common law and does not have any specific statutory enactments. Precedents include Partridge v Crittenden [1968] and Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company [1892].

Application: The facts of the case study present that Malcolm writes a letter to Linda stating that he wants to sell his sports car for $4,500, to which Linda replies that she would need time to think about the offer. Malcolm states that she had till Monday the 19th of July to let him know about the same. Evidently, no contract is formed between Malcolm and Linda in this regard. The judgement passed in the matter of “Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company [1892] EWCA Civ 1” is relevant here, which stated that contracts must include five essential elements comprised of an offer, an acceptance, an intention to create legally binding relations, valid consideration and legality within both the form an consent (Australian Contract Law, 2020). Malcolm’s intention to sell the car would be considered as an offer where as the provision of the information that Linda had till Monday to let him know about it would be an invitation to treat as established in the case of Partridge v Crittenden [1968] 1 WLR 1204” (, 2020).Naturally, no contract was formed between the two based on the facts contained within the scenario. Furthermore, the scenario presents that Cynthia, Malcolm’s supervisor agrees to buy the car for $5,000 to which Malcolm promptly agrees. It would result in the formation of a contract whereby Malcolm would be liable to perform the contractual obligations of transferring the ownership of the car to Cynthia for the agreed sum.

Interestingly, the scenario presents that Linda subsequently goes on to send a letter to Malcolm accepting his offer to sell the car at $4.500. However, the letter is not delivered to Malcolm till the 19th of July. It could be inferred that a contract regarding the selling of the car has already been formed between Malcolm and Cynthia on the 15th of July, which would negate the acceptance by Linda that Malcolm came to know of on the19th. Acceptance of an offer must be clearly communicated as established in the case of Felthouse v Bindley [1862] EWHC J35, [1862] 142 ER 1037” (Jackson, 2019).

Conclusion: Considering the application of precedents to the scenario, Malcolm would have contractual obligations towards Cynthia but not towards Linda.

Question 2

Issue: The issue within the case scenario relates to whether the agreement between Modern Media Sounds and Concert Sales is a joint venture or a partnership.

Rule: Partnerships are governed by individual state legislations within Australia, albeit a federal statue exists in the form of the Partnership Act 1963. Joint ventures are not expressly governed within Australia and are subject to both statutory as well as common law provisions. Statutory provisions include the Corporations Act 2001 predominantly while common law provisions include contract and agency law and others.

Application: The facts of the scenario present that Modern Media Sounds and Concert Sales entered into a written agreement where the interests for the Australian tours of Tyler Slow were divided equally. The contracts were specifically set to be performed as a joint venture, where the net profits were agreed upon mutually to be divided at the end of the contract. Considering the fact that the agreement between the two entities was entered into specifically in the form of a joint venture, the agreement could not be held as a partnership. The fact that the agreement was in the form of a joint venture is further solidified within the case study as it presents that the losses were not to be shared on the same basis as that of the profits. Moreover, partnerships typically entail an ongoing relationship to achieve a common purpose, but joint ventures entail two or more parties working together while maintaining their individual separate identities.

An important case law in this regard is the matter of “Adventure Golf Systems Australia Pty Ltd v Belgravia Health & Leisure Group Pty Ltd [2017] VSCA 326” where an agreement between disputing parties that created fiduciary duties was held to be a joint venture owing to the absence of the characteristics of a partnership (Victorian Reports, 2020). The features of a partnership are stated comprehensively in the case of United Dominions Corporation Ltd v Brian Pty Ltd (1985) 157 CLR 1” that includes equal sharing of profits and losses (High Court of Australia, 2020). Naturally, owing to the differentiated agreements regarding profits and losses between Modern Media Sounds and Concert Sales, the agreement would be considered as a joint venture and not a partnership.

Conclusion: The agreement between the two entities does not entail the features and characteristic as required to constitute a partnership and would be classified as a joint venture.

Question 3

The case scenario puts forwards that Oldskool Pty Ltd comprised of an old fashioned memorandum of association, which included an objects clause that limited the scope of the company’s operations to development, manufacturing and selling of commercial computing devices. Josie, a major shareholder within the company has identified that Oldskool could potentially expand its operations into remote office management software and mobile applications given the needs of the changing times. Considering the validity of the memorandum of association, companies registered within Australia are not longer required to maintain memorandum or articles since the introduction of the Replaceable Rules on the 1st of July, 1998. It is important to note that companies that have been in operations prior to the date of the introduction of Replaceable Rules could continue relying on their memorandum and articles as the constitution (Legal Vision, 2020). Based on the facts contained in the case scenario, the company would have to amend its memorandum of association to enter into new contracts or repeal their constitution and implement the Replaceable Rules as contained in Section 141 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Australasian Legal Information Institute, 2020). The repeal would have to be carried out in accordance to the provisions contained in Section 135(2) of the Corporations Act 2001.

In terms of how the replaceable rules may be of benefit to Oldskool Pty Ltd in the future, it would be important to discuss the convenience entailed within the implementation of the same. While a modification of the memorandum of association would be time consuming and inconvenience, incorporating the Replaceable Rules as the constitution would be comparatively more convenient as well as more cost effective. It would also allow the company to engage in operations beyond the scope mentioned within the memorandum of association, which in the case of Oldskool Pty Ltd was limited to the development and sale of computing devices. Another very prominent area of relevance for Replaceable Rules in terms of how it could benefit Oldskool Pty Ltd is that the company management could very easily switch back to a constitution in the form of a memorandum and an article of association. Private companies are required to issue a mere 21 day notice for the same in the context of incorporating the constitution through a general meeting (Australian Institute of Company Directors, 2020).

Question 4

Issue: The issue within the case study relates to whether Harry contact all the members of Eaglefly Aviation Ltd. and how along with whether the company can prevent Harry from contacting the company members.

Rule: Standing proxies are governed by Section 250A of the Corporations Act 2001.

Application: The facts of the case scenario present that Harry, a member of Eaglefly Aviation Ltd, which is a public company listed on the Australian Stock Exchange seeks to contact the other members of the company in order to obtain standing proxies. In terms of the reasons behind the decision, Harry feels that the company management has failed to govern the operations in an appropriate manner, which has led to a drastic fall in the share price for the company. Regarding whether Harry could contact the members of the company, it would certainly be possible in terms of the members’ rights to participate in the decisions of the company that are reserved for the shareholders (Thomson Reuters Practical Law, 2020). Furthermore, the contact would be in line with maintaining the interests of the company since the current situation was rather poor and the senior management was failing to adapt to the changing needs of the aviation industry.

Harry could contact the members either verbally or in a written manner, but the proxies would have to be obtained though signed documents including the members name and address, the company’s name, the proxy’s name and the meeting during which the appointment would be used. This is in accordance to the provisions contained in Section 250A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Australasian Legal Information Institute, 2020). In terms of whether Eaglefly Aviation Ltd could prevent Harry from contacting the other members, there is no express mention of any relevant clause within the Corporations Act 2001. However, it a clause is present within the constitution of the company where it has been expressly mentioned that the company could prevent any member from contacting another member regarding obtaining a proxy, Eaglefly Aviation could certainly exercise the clause and prevent Harry from contacting all the members.

Conclusion: It is concluded that Harry would be able to contact all the members of Eaglefly Aviation Ltd. either verbally or through written documentation, but the proxies would have to be obtained through signed correspondences from the other members. The company could not prevent Harry from contacting the other members by default unless it was expressly mentioned within the company constitution.

Question 5

Issue: The issue in the case scenario relates to whether Leonard would be successful in a claim for negligence against Coolies Pty Ltd.

Rule: Negligence is not governed by any specific statutory enactment within Australia and comes under the purview of the common law system and precedents. The case of Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] is relevant in this regard. The Work Health and Safety Act 2011 along with the Work Health and Safety Regulations 2011 governs workplace safety within Australia.

Application: The facts of the case present that Leonard received an injury on his back in 2018, after which he underwent a spinal surgery and returned to his work in 2019. Following the incident, Leonard complained that his back was getting increasingly sore while lifting boxes, to which the company responded with the provision of a hydraulic lifting machine for his assistance. However, Leonard saw that the forklift was limiting his efficiency, as a result of which he began lifting the boxes physically and went on to injuring himself severely, rendering himself unable to work in the packaging industry anymore. In terms of whether Leonard would be successful in a claim for negligence against Coolies Pty Ltd, it would be important to discuss the elements of negligence as established in the case of Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562” (Sir Harry Gibbs Legal Heritage Centre, 2020).

Key requirements to establish a case of negligence included the duty of care, breach of the duty of care, injury due to the breach of duty or omission and causation. Considering that Leonard was an employee of Coolies, the organisation was bound to factor in Leonard’s safety when within the workplace premises in accordance to the Work Health and Safety Regulations 2011. In the context of the issue of negligence, Coolies maintained its duty of care towards Leonard by providing him with a hydraulic lifting machine. Furthermore, the fact that Leonard is no longer able to work within the packaging industry is due to him refraining from using the machine as it slowed down his efficiency. The aspect of contributory negligence is relevant in this regard, whereby Leonard’s own actions led to him receiving the injury, thus protecting Coolies from any tort claims based on negligence at later stages. The judgement passed in the matter of Podresbersek v Australian Iron and Steel Pty Ltd [1985] HCA 34; 59 ALR 492” is relevant in this regard, where the claims for damages due to negligence were not held owing to the lack of safety and care shown by the applicant (D’Alessandri, 2014).

Conclusion: Leonard would not be able to claim a case for negligence against Coolies owing to the exception of contributory negligence that would be applicable to the company as a defense.


Australasian Legal Information Institute. (2020). CORPORATIONS ACT 2001 – SECT 141 Table of replaceable rules. Retrieved 24 July 2020, from

Australasian Legal Information Institute. (2020). CORPORATIONS ACT 2001 – SECT 250A Appointing a proxy. Retrieved 24 July 2020, from

Australian Contract Law (2020). Case | Carlill. Retrieved 24 July 2020, from

Australian Institute of Company Directors. (2020). General meetings of members. Retrieved 24 July 2020, from

D’Alessandri, L. (2014). New test for contributory negligence – The Court of Appeal has implemented a new test for contributory negligence, particularly when considering accidents involving pedestrians – Court of Appeal, NSW. Retrieved 24 July 2020, from (2020). Partridge v Crittenden. Retrieved 24 July 2020, from

High Court of Australia. (2020). UNITED DOMINIONS CORPORATION LTD. v. BRIAN PTY. LTD. Retrieved 24 July 2020, from–UNITED_DOMINIONS_CORPORATION_LTD._v._BRIAN_PTY._LTD–(1985)_157_CLR_1.html

Jackson, N. (2019). Felthouse v Bindley [1862] EWHC CP J35; 142 ER 1037. Oxford University Press. Retrieved from

Legal Vision. (2020). What are Memorandum and Articles of Association?. Retrieved 24 July 2020, from

Sir Harry Gibbs Legal Heritage Centre. (2020).Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562. Retrieved 24 July 2020, from

Thomson Reuters Practical Law. (2020). Shareholders’ rights in private and public companies in Australia. Retrieved 24 July 2020, from

Victorian Reports (2020). Adventure Golf Systems Australia Pty Ltd v Belgravia Health & Leisure Group Pty Ltd. Retrieved 24 July 2020, from

Order Now

Get solved or fresh solution on BUSINESS AND CORPORATE LAW Case study and many more. 24X7 help, plag free solution. Order online now!

Universal Assignment (September 27, 2022) BUSINESS AND CORPORATE LAW Case study Questions Assignment Solved. Retrieved from
"BUSINESS AND CORPORATE LAW Case study Questions Assignment Solved." Universal Assignment - September 27, 2022,
Universal Assignment July 24, 2022 BUSINESS AND CORPORATE LAW Case study Questions Assignment Solved., viewed September 27, 2022,<>
Universal Assignment - BUSINESS AND CORPORATE LAW Case study Questions Assignment Solved. [Internet]. [Accessed September 27, 2022]. Available from:
"BUSINESS AND CORPORATE LAW Case study Questions Assignment Solved." Universal Assignment - Accessed September 27, 2022.
"BUSINESS AND CORPORATE LAW Case study Questions Assignment Solved." Universal Assignment [Online]. Available: [Accessed: September 27, 2022]

Please note along with our service, we will provide you with the following deliverables:

Please do not hesitate to put forward any queries regarding the service provision.

We look forward to having you on board with us.

Get 45%* OFF on Assignment Help

Popular Assignments

VU22977 – Practice in a Legal Environment

Advanced Diploma of Legal Practice – 22565VIC PORTFOLIO- CLIENT MATTER FILE Assessment task 1 Prepare a comprehensive portfolio of documents to create a Client Matter File which must include: Element 1 Area of law Cover sheet stating client name and short description of legal matter Client Instruction Sheet, Costs Agreement

Read More »

KIT714 ICT Research Principles: Assignment 1

Practical Qualitative Research Exercise                                                                                                                                         Type:                 In-Semester, Individual Assignment Task Length:   minimum 2,000 words Weighting:     20% of total assessment for this unit Due Date:       Friday 5 August 2022 – 11:55 pm (Week05) Submission:    electronic submission on MyLO (WORD or PDF) Description:    This practical exercise will engage students in a qualitative research

Read More »

MODULE 44-704463 Dissertation Help

ASSESSMENT CRITERIA Dissertation (12,500 words) Deadline: JULY 29th 2022, 3pm Introduction and abstract  Situates the research question within the, theory, and concepts Explains the value of the study.  Relevance of the research question, to the field of study is fully justified. Leads logically into the Literature Review. Abstract of professional

Read More »

ITECH1103-Assignment: Assignment 2: Analytics Report

Overview The purpose of this task is to provide students with practical experience in writing a data analytical report to provide useful insights, patterns, and trends in a chosen dataset in the light of a set of tasks required within this document. This dataset will be chosen from the UC

Read More »

PBHL20001 Term 1, 2022 – Supplementary Assessment

PBHL20001 Term 1, 2022 Supplementary Assessment The influenza pandemic that followed World War I and took place over the period from 1918-1920 resulted in an estimated 100 million deaths worldwide and 500 million infections. In addition, this pandemic had a significant impact on public health practice throughout the 20th century

Read More »

Community Health Project 1 (HLTH 3058): Assessment 2: Portfolio Task 2

Community Health Project 1 (HLTH 3058) Assessment 2: Portfolio Task 2 – Evaluative Framework Marking Guide Weighting: 15% the total grade for the course   Criteria Outstanding performance (75-100%) Exceeds core requirements (65-74%) Meets core requirements (50-64%) Does not meet requirements (<50%) Comments Content (70%) Demonstrates adequate knowledge of integrating

Read More »

Community Health Project 1 (HLTH 3058): Assessment 2: Portfolio Task 1

Community Health Project 1 (HLTH 3058)Assessment 2: Portfolio Task 1 – Ethical Considerations Marking GuideWeighting of 15% the total grade for the course Criteria Outstanding performance (75-100%) Exceeds core requirements (65-74%)   Meets core requirements (50-64%) Does not meet requirements (<50%) Comments CONTENT (80%) Ethical Considerations   Demonstrates adequate knowledge

Read More »

SAM 11486/SAM G 6677: Assignment 1 – Individual

Assignment 1 – Individual (25%) Report Due: 11:59pm Sunday Week 5 04/09/2022 This assignment will be marked out of 25 marks and is worth 25% of the overall mark for the unit. Please check the unit outline for late penalties and restrictions on late submissions. This assignment is an individual

Read More »

11486 Systems Analysis and Modelling

Assignment Case Study C – Feed Me Now Disclaimer: The situation described in the following case study is fictional, and bears no resemblance to any persons, businesses, or organisations, living or dead. Any such resemblance, if exists, is merely co-incidental in nature, and is not intentional. Feed Me Now is

Read More »

MAA703 – Accounting for Management

Trimester 2 2022 Assessment Task 2 Part B – Teamwork Reflection (Individual) DUE DATE AND TIME:                        Wednesday, 7 September 2022 by 8:00pm (AEST) PERCENTAGE OF FINAL GRADE:    10% WORD COUNT:                                   750 – 800 words Description Teamwork is one of the vital components of many workplaces and the ability to demonstrate

Read More »

Research project assessment proforma and marking schemes

BSc Biomedical Sciences with Health, Exercise and Nutrition (HEN6004) and BSc Biomedical Science (APS6022) Instructions for use All forms must be completed electronically and uploaded to the student submission point in  turnitin. Please note the literature review assessment will be completed in January whereas the assessment of the paper/poster and

Read More »

XERO and Spotlight reporting software Report Assignment

Case facts – Read me carefully please City Infrastructure Holdings Ltd (CIH) and Network Maintenance Services Ltd (NMS) City Infrastructure Holdings Ltd (CIH) acquired 100% of the 300,000 issued shares in Network Maintenance Services (NMS) on 1 July 2021.  The consideration provided to shareholders of NMS consisted of $1.20 in cash plus 1

Read More »

KIT103 Computational Science

School of Information and Communication Technology College of Sciences and Engineering Unit Outline KIT103 Computational Science Semester 2, 2022 Sandy Bay Campus, Hobart Newnham Campus, Launceston COVID-19 (Coronavirus Information) For information on how you can help keep us all safe, please review the Coronavirus updates page here: Sections that

Read More »

SEN725 Urban Stormwater Asset Design

Assessment Task -4 Final Report – Analysis of CoGG Stormwater Network Weight 50% This is an individual assessment task. Plagiarism and collusion is unacceptable practice at Deakin University. You must appropriately reference your work. Failure to do so will result in disciplinary action. For more information on plagiarism and collusion,

Read More »

PSY3PRP 2022 Assignment 2: Research Project Report

PSY3PRP 2022 Assignment 2: Research Project Report Guidelines and Marking Rubric Individual Research Report due Wednesday 19th October 11.59pm (50% of total grade) For this assignment—with support through structured tutorial work across much of the semester— you will produce an individually-written report on the broad topic of feeding difficulties in

Read More »

Increasing Demand for assignment help in Namibia

With the growing population, the demand for clean energy, advanced technology, new structures, and better healthcare is escalating day by day which makes engineering the most popular degree for the youth. As more people pursue engineering nowadays, it also makes it one of the most difficult and competitive degrees also.

Read More »

Online Assignment Help in Germany

How Could You Do Exam Preparation Effectively? Exam time is full of challenges and difficulties. You have to juggle exams even in high school, college, or higher education. It defines your knowledge of a specific subject and how well you know the curriculum. The exam also tests how much you

Read More »

Get Excellent Human Values Assignment Help Immediately

Get Excellent Human Values Assignment Help Immediately: Expert Solutions to all your Queries Instant Human Values Assignment Help Online Students can get Human Values assignment help online in a fast and simple way from the experts at Universal Assignment Help Service. Their team of over 172+ subject experts works every

Read More »

Get Top Modern History Assignment Help Online

Order Modern History Assignment Help immediately Students often need modern history assignment help for many reasons. Getting immediate online help for assignments helps students boost their academics in incredible ways. Sometimes, the pressure of studies is too much to take for students. This causes them to score poor grades and

Read More »

Get Instant Assignment Help in the United Arab Emirates

How Can Assignments Help Students? Whatever the definition of homework is, one thing is certain: it helps students thoroughly learn the concepts they have studied in class. The number of such assignments may cause stress or a burden. It means students and tutors are both correct in their type of

Read More »

Assignment Help in Mexico

How to Gain Awesome Grades in Your Chemistry Subject? Whether you are pursuing a technical degree or studying in the science stream, chemistry is always at the forefront. If you love to observe reactions, molecules, acids, condensation, evaporation, and dilution, chemistry will prove a resource for getting outstanding academic marks.

Read More »

Assignment Help in Kenya

How Could You Find the Best Biology Homework Website? Getting online homework help from an expert is neither embarrassing nor unauthentic. The vast majority of students around the world believe that doing online assignments and tutoring is beneficial. The Standard Graduate School of Education revealed that 56% of students suffer

Read More »

Assignment Help in Bangladesh

The Best 6 Hacks to Shortlist the Top Civil Engineering Assignment Tutor? Finding a homework expert for civil engineering assignments is a hectic task. As civil engineering has several fields, getting expertise is difficult for tutors. You may struggle to receive civil engineering assignment help in Bangladesh due to this

Read More »

Assignment Help in Pakistan

What Will Unethical Occur from Getting Homework? Homework looks like a mode of learning in most cases. But what happens to its quantity? Its quantity should be more than enough for students. Such circumstances may be detrimental to the health of the pupils. Sometimes, college faculties or teachers forget to

Read More »

Assignment Help in Malaysia

The Best 4 Skills You Should Learn For Making Your Career in 2022 As technological innovations leap forward daily, new skills are entering our market. Sticking to one skill set enables you to lose lucrative job opportunities. That is why it gives importance to having diverse skills, which should be

Read More »

MKT200 Marketing Principles: Infographic

Assessment 2 Information Subject Code: MKT200 Subject Name: Marketing Principles Assessment Title: Infographic Assessment Type: Individual infographic Length: Two pages Weighting: 30% Total Marks: 100 Submission: Online Due Date: Week 9 Your task Individually, you are required to create a two-page infographic outlining the communications process of two competitor brands.

Read More »

MMP-223, Property and Real Estate Law and Practice

MMP-223, Property and Real Estate Law and Practice, Trimester 2, 2022 Assignment 2, Client Report, Individual Assignment 25% of Unit Assessment (1,250 words*) Due Date: September 16, 2022, 8-pm AEST Assignment Brief: Clyde, being a real estate agent, loves property. With his share of the sale of the Sorrento property

Read More »

NUR1398 – Foundations of Nursing Practice Theory

Assessment: Care Plan Report Task overview Course NUR1398 – Foundations of Nursing Practice Theory Brief task description Written care plan addressing nursing care requirements for older patients with degenerative conditions. Rationale for assessment task Registered Nurses are required to think through the different aspects of patient care to arrive at

Read More »

MBA641 Project Strategy Framework

Assessment 1 Information Subject Code: MBA641 Subject Name: Strategic Project Management Assessment Title: Project Strategy Framework Assessment Type: Length: Individual video recording and supporting Infographic Video: 10-minute (no more) Supporting infographic: 1 page (no more) Weighting: 30% Total Marks: Submission: 100 Online Due Date: Week 4 Your task You are

Read More »

SEJ201 Structural Design Assessment

SEJ201 Structural Design Assessment Task 5 FINAL PROJECT REPORT Summary The Final Project Report is an individual task which builds on teamwork completed earlier in the trimester. This report shall clearly explain and justify the design solution proposed. In this report students you should identify project scope, inputs and constraints,

Read More »

42907 Design for Durability

Introduction Overall, explain what readers will find in the report, general information about the structure, location, climatic conditions, detail which specific parts of the structure will be designed according to which Australian standard. Which type of foundation, why? You can use figures in this section. Provide the scope of the

Read More »

Can't Find Your Assignment?

Open chat
Free Assistance
Universal Assignment
Hello 👋
How can we help you?