EVIDENCE AND THE LITIGATION PROCESS LAW1306 Assignment

EVIDENCE AND THE LITIGATION PROCESS

COURSE CODE: LAW1306

ASSIGNMENT #1 –CASE BRIEF

PREJUDICE

ADMISSION OF EVIDENCE AS IT RELATES TO HEARSAY AND EXCEPTIONS

SUBMISSION DATE: JULY 14, 2022

STUDENTS NAMES:

RANJIT KAUR

&

HARMAN SINGH

  1. R v Khelawon [2006] SCC 57
  1. FACTS OF THE CASE
  1. Mr. Ramnarion Kelawon is the manager of Bloor West Retirement Village which has about 40 elderly persons who needs special care. Therefore, In the year 1999, five residents complained against the manager of the retirement home for assault.
  2. Joanna Stangrat is a cook as well as assistant at the retirement home. One day she found Mr. Skupien laid in his bed with blood near mouth and several injuries. She saw her clothes packed in garbage bag. Immediately, she took him to some different place away from the retirement place.
  3. Doctor’s report showed that he got three ribs fractured. Later, she took him to the police station where his statement was videotaped about the incident that took place with him.
  4. During the time of trial, four complainants died due to old age and the remaining was unable to testify. Mr. Skupien died before trial.
  5. ISSUE INVOLVED
  6. Whether the Hearsay statement is admissible?
  7. ANALYSIS
  1. The statement made by Mr. Skupien to cook, doctor and police involved hearsay which was presumptively inadmissible. The analysis can be drawn based upon the reasoning given by Charron J. As per basic rule of evidence, all the relevant evidence are admissible in the court. But there are certain exceptions related to this including hearsay as one of them. The term ‘hearsay’ basically means ‘out-of-court statement’ which is adduced to prove the truth of its contents. Thus, it is presumptively inadmissible until it satisfies one of the traditional exceptions to the hearsay rule.
  2. If it does not satisfy the traditional exceptions, then it must follow the principled approach to find the necessity and reliability depending upon the situation of the case. In case of necessity, it comes into consideration because the person who made the statement is not available to give the statement in the court or has changed the statement. In case of reliability, there should be some trustworthiness in the statement even if it is not made under an oath. Following are two tests applicable here:
  • The Threshold Test: This test is related to the relevance and materiality of the case. In the present case, whether the hearsay is reliable?
  • The Necessity Test: This test defines that the only way to admit the evidence would be hearsay. Whether the hearsay is necessary in this case?
  1. Furthermore, the case relied on expert evidence which stated that the injuries suffered by the elderly person could be due to fall or beating. Because four complainants were already died, and the only piece of evidence was videotaped statement. Also, it was mentioned by the experts that the things stated in the video were questionable due to low mental efficiency in old age. This showed the lack of reliability of hearsay.
  2. Thus, the court held that it did not meet reliability. Hence, hearsay is not admissible.
  1. CONCLUSION
  2. Therefore, it can be concluded that the Hearsay evidence is only admissible in the court if it meets the particular exceptions that allows them to be admitted. Hearsay should be of such nature which meets both necessity and reliability relevant to the case to apply the exclusionary rule. Although, the traditional exceptions are relevant, but they must meet the necessity and reliability as important concepts related to the hearsay.
Order Now

Get expert help for your EVIDENCE AND THE LITIGATION PROCESS LAW1306 Assignment and many more. Plag free, the best service in Australia, 100% safe. Order Now!

No Fields Found.
Universal Assignment (September 28, 2022) EVIDENCE AND THE LITIGATION PROCESS LAW1306 Assignment. Retrieved from https://universalassignment.com/evidence-and-the-litigation-process-law1306-assignment/.
"EVIDENCE AND THE LITIGATION PROCESS LAW1306 Assignment." Universal Assignment - September 28, 2022, https://universalassignment.com/evidence-and-the-litigation-process-law1306-assignment/
Universal Assignment July 4, 2022 EVIDENCE AND THE LITIGATION PROCESS LAW1306 Assignment., viewed September 28, 2022,<https://universalassignment.com/evidence-and-the-litigation-process-law1306-assignment/>
Universal Assignment - EVIDENCE AND THE LITIGATION PROCESS LAW1306 Assignment. [Internet]. [Accessed September 28, 2022]. Available from: https://universalassignment.com/evidence-and-the-litigation-process-law1306-assignment/
"EVIDENCE AND THE LITIGATION PROCESS LAW1306 Assignment." Universal Assignment - Accessed September 28, 2022. https://universalassignment.com/evidence-and-the-litigation-process-law1306-assignment/
"EVIDENCE AND THE LITIGATION PROCESS LAW1306 Assignment." Universal Assignment [Online]. Available: https://universalassignment.com/evidence-and-the-litigation-process-law1306-assignment/. [Accessed: September 28, 2022]

Please note along with our service, we will provide you with the following deliverables:

Please do not hesitate to put forward any queries regarding the service provision.

We look forward to having you on board with us.

Get 45%* OFF on Assignment Help

Popular Assignments

VU22977 – Practice in a Legal Environment

Advanced Diploma of Legal Practice – 22565VIC PORTFOLIO- CLIENT MATTER FILE Assessment task 1 Prepare a comprehensive portfolio of documents to create a Client Matter File which must include: Element 1 Area of law Cover sheet stating client name and short description of legal matter Client Instruction Sheet, Costs Agreement

Read More »

KIT714 ICT Research Principles: Assignment 1

Practical Qualitative Research Exercise                                                                                                                                         Type:                 In-Semester, Individual Assignment Task Length:   minimum 2,000 words Weighting:     20% of total assessment for this unit Due Date:       Friday 5 August 2022 – 11:55 pm (Week05) Submission:    electronic submission on MyLO (WORD or PDF) Description:    This practical exercise will engage students in a qualitative research

Read More »

MODULE 44-704463 Dissertation Help

ASSESSMENT CRITERIA Dissertation (12,500 words) Deadline: JULY 29th 2022, 3pm Introduction and abstract  Situates the research question within the, theory, and concepts Explains the value of the study.  Relevance of the research question, to the field of study is fully justified. Leads logically into the Literature Review. Abstract of professional

Read More »

ITECH1103-Assignment: Assignment 2: Analytics Report

Overview The purpose of this task is to provide students with practical experience in writing a data analytical report to provide useful insights, patterns, and trends in a chosen dataset in the light of a set of tasks required within this document. This dataset will be chosen from the UC

Read More »

PBHL20001 Term 1, 2022 – Supplementary Assessment

PBHL20001 Term 1, 2022 Supplementary Assessment The influenza pandemic that followed World War I and took place over the period from 1918-1920 resulted in an estimated 100 million deaths worldwide and 500 million infections. In addition, this pandemic had a significant impact on public health practice throughout the 20th century

Read More »

Community Health Project 1 (HLTH 3058): Assessment 2: Portfolio Task 2

Community Health Project 1 (HLTH 3058) Assessment 2: Portfolio Task 2 – Evaluative Framework Marking Guide Weighting: 15% the total grade for the course   Criteria Outstanding performance (75-100%) Exceeds core requirements (65-74%) Meets core requirements (50-64%) Does not meet requirements (<50%) Comments Content (70%) Demonstrates adequate knowledge of integrating

Read More »

Community Health Project 1 (HLTH 3058): Assessment 2: Portfolio Task 1

Community Health Project 1 (HLTH 3058)Assessment 2: Portfolio Task 1 – Ethical Considerations Marking GuideWeighting of 15% the total grade for the course Criteria Outstanding performance (75-100%) Exceeds core requirements (65-74%)   Meets core requirements (50-64%) Does not meet requirements (<50%) Comments CONTENT (80%) Ethical Considerations   Demonstrates adequate knowledge

Read More »

SAM 11486/SAM G 6677: Assignment 1 – Individual

Assignment 1 – Individual (25%) Report Due: 11:59pm Sunday Week 5 04/09/2022 This assignment will be marked out of 25 marks and is worth 25% of the overall mark for the unit. Please check the unit outline for late penalties and restrictions on late submissions. This assignment is an individual

Read More »

11486 Systems Analysis and Modelling

Assignment Case Study C – Feed Me Now Disclaimer: The situation described in the following case study is fictional, and bears no resemblance to any persons, businesses, or organisations, living or dead. Any such resemblance, if exists, is merely co-incidental in nature, and is not intentional. Feed Me Now is

Read More »

MAA703 – Accounting for Management

Trimester 2 2022 Assessment Task 2 Part B – Teamwork Reflection (Individual) DUE DATE AND TIME:                        Wednesday, 7 September 2022 by 8:00pm (AEST) PERCENTAGE OF FINAL GRADE:    10% WORD COUNT:                                   750 – 800 words Description Teamwork is one of the vital components of many workplaces and the ability to demonstrate

Read More »

Research project assessment proforma and marking schemes

BSc Biomedical Sciences with Health, Exercise and Nutrition (HEN6004) and BSc Biomedical Science (APS6022) Instructions for use All forms must be completed electronically and uploaded to the student submission point in  turnitin. Please note the literature review assessment will be completed in January whereas the assessment of the paper/poster and

Read More »

XERO and Spotlight reporting software Report Assignment

Case facts – Read me carefully please City Infrastructure Holdings Ltd (CIH) and Network Maintenance Services Ltd (NMS) City Infrastructure Holdings Ltd (CIH) acquired 100% of the 300,000 issued shares in Network Maintenance Services (NMS) on 1 July 2021.  The consideration provided to shareholders of NMS consisted of $1.20 in cash plus 1

Read More »

KIT103 Computational Science

School of Information and Communication Technology College of Sciences and Engineering Unit Outline KIT103 Computational Science Semester 2, 2022 Sandy Bay Campus, Hobart Newnham Campus, Launceston COVID-19 (Coronavirus Information) For information on how you can help keep us all safe, please review the Coronavirus updates page here: https://www.utas.edu.au/about/safety-security-and-wellbeing/coronavirus Sections that

Read More »

SEN725 Urban Stormwater Asset Design

Assessment Task -4 Final Report – Analysis of CoGG Stormwater Network Weight 50% This is an individual assessment task. Plagiarism and collusion is unacceptable practice at Deakin University. You must appropriately reference your work. Failure to do so will result in disciplinary action. For more information on plagiarism and collusion,

Read More »

PSY3PRP 2022 Assignment 2: Research Project Report

PSY3PRP 2022 Assignment 2: Research Project Report Guidelines and Marking Rubric Individual Research Report due Wednesday 19th October 11.59pm (50% of total grade) For this assignment—with support through structured tutorial work across much of the semester— you will produce an individually-written report on the broad topic of feeding difficulties in

Read More »

Increasing Demand for assignment help in Namibia

With the growing population, the demand for clean energy, advanced technology, new structures, and better healthcare is escalating day by day which makes engineering the most popular degree for the youth. As more people pursue engineering nowadays, it also makes it one of the most difficult and competitive degrees also.

Read More »

Online Assignment Help in Germany

How Could You Do Exam Preparation Effectively? Exam time is full of challenges and difficulties. You have to juggle exams even in high school, college, or higher education. It defines your knowledge of a specific subject and how well you know the curriculum. The exam also tests how much you

Read More »

Get Excellent Human Values Assignment Help Immediately

Get Excellent Human Values Assignment Help Immediately: Expert Solutions to all your Queries Instant Human Values Assignment Help Online Students can get Human Values assignment help online in a fast and simple way from the experts at Universal Assignment Help Service. Their team of over 172+ subject experts works every

Read More »

Get Top Modern History Assignment Help Online

Order Modern History Assignment Help immediately Students often need modern history assignment help for many reasons. Getting immediate online help for assignments helps students boost their academics in incredible ways. Sometimes, the pressure of studies is too much to take for students. This causes them to score poor grades and

Read More »

Get Instant Assignment Help in the United Arab Emirates

How Can Assignments Help Students? Whatever the definition of homework is, one thing is certain: it helps students thoroughly learn the concepts they have studied in class. The number of such assignments may cause stress or a burden. It means students and tutors are both correct in their type of

Read More »

Assignment Help in Mexico

How to Gain Awesome Grades in Your Chemistry Subject? Whether you are pursuing a technical degree or studying in the science stream, chemistry is always at the forefront. If you love to observe reactions, molecules, acids, condensation, evaporation, and dilution, chemistry will prove a resource for getting outstanding academic marks.

Read More »

Assignment Help in Kenya

How Could You Find the Best Biology Homework Website? Getting online homework help from an expert is neither embarrassing nor unauthentic. The vast majority of students around the world believe that doing online assignments and tutoring is beneficial. The Standard Graduate School of Education revealed that 56% of students suffer

Read More »

Assignment Help in Bangladesh

The Best 6 Hacks to Shortlist the Top Civil Engineering Assignment Tutor? Finding a homework expert for civil engineering assignments is a hectic task. As civil engineering has several fields, getting expertise is difficult for tutors. You may struggle to receive civil engineering assignment help in Bangladesh due to this

Read More »

Assignment Help in Pakistan

What Will Unethical Occur from Getting Homework? Homework looks like a mode of learning in most cases. But what happens to its quantity? Its quantity should be more than enough for students. Such circumstances may be detrimental to the health of the pupils. Sometimes, college faculties or teachers forget to

Read More »

Assignment Help in Malaysia

The Best 4 Skills You Should Learn For Making Your Career in 2022 As technological innovations leap forward daily, new skills are entering our market. Sticking to one skill set enables you to lose lucrative job opportunities. That is why it gives importance to having diverse skills, which should be

Read More »

MKT200 Marketing Principles: Infographic

Assessment 2 Information Subject Code: MKT200 Subject Name: Marketing Principles Assessment Title: Infographic Assessment Type: Individual infographic Length: Two pages Weighting: 30% Total Marks: 100 Submission: Online Due Date: Week 9 Your task Individually, you are required to create a two-page infographic outlining the communications process of two competitor brands.

Read More »

MMP-223, Property and Real Estate Law and Practice

MMP-223, Property and Real Estate Law and Practice, Trimester 2, 2022 Assignment 2, Client Report, Individual Assignment 25% of Unit Assessment (1,250 words*) Due Date: September 16, 2022, 8-pm AEST Assignment Brief: Clyde, being a real estate agent, loves property. With his share of the sale of the Sorrento property

Read More »

NUR1398 – Foundations of Nursing Practice Theory

Assessment: Care Plan Report Task overview Course NUR1398 – Foundations of Nursing Practice Theory Brief task description Written care plan addressing nursing care requirements for older patients with degenerative conditions. Rationale for assessment task Registered Nurses are required to think through the different aspects of patient care to arrive at

Read More »

MBA641 Project Strategy Framework

Assessment 1 Information Subject Code: MBA641 Subject Name: Strategic Project Management Assessment Title: Project Strategy Framework Assessment Type: Length: Individual video recording and supporting Infographic Video: 10-minute (no more) Supporting infographic: 1 page (no more) Weighting: 30% Total Marks: Submission: 100 Online Due Date: Week 4 Your task You are

Read More »

SEJ201 Structural Design Assessment

SEJ201 Structural Design Assessment Task 5 FINAL PROJECT REPORT Summary The Final Project Report is an individual task which builds on teamwork completed earlier in the trimester. This report shall clearly explain and justify the design solution proposed. In this report students you should identify project scope, inputs and constraints,

Read More »

42907 Design for Durability

Introduction Overall, explain what readers will find in the report, general information about the structure, location, climatic conditions, detail which specific parts of the structure will be designed according to which Australian standard. Which type of foundation, why? You can use figures in this section. Provide the scope of the

Read More »

Can't Find Your Assignment?

Open chat
1
Free Assistance
Universal Assignment
Hello 👋
How can we help you?