Formal Evaluation Techniques In The Decision Making Process Assignment [SOLVED]

Capital Budgeting: A Case Study Analysis of The Role Of Formal Evaluation Techniques In The Decision Making Process For Answering The Provided Questions. 

Table of Contents

Introduction 2

Background of case study 2

Cost structure 2

Capital budgeting process 3

Consideration of other factors for decision making 4

Critical review and evaluation 4

Conclusion 5

Recommendations 5

References 6


Capital budgeting is important for the organisations to improve measurability of finance and accountability that helps them to invest proper resources for the project after identifying the risks. The long-term investment and expenditure can be identified by the companies to ensure business suitability and gain competitive advantage in the market (Fehrenbacher et al., 2020). The present report analyses the capital budgeting process of two companies that are mentioned in the case studies and evaluates the factors that are considered for their decision making.

Background of case study

It is identified in the case study that the Firm A focuses on relocating their sisal matting plant from Polokwane in order to cost minimisation and export promotion. As there is limitation for product diversification in the sisal carpeting market, relocating can provide competitive advantage to the company. Polokwane production plant has low levels of productivity and losses relative cost advantages and there is also increasing importance of export sales that is almost 30% of total sales of this firm (Gilbert, 2015). Therefore, the decision regarding relocation of the production unit has utmost importance for Firm A.

On the other hand, as per another case study, South African paper manufacturing company, Firm B initiates the capital investment decision making process to increase their production capacity for long term profitability, high operating efficiencies and continuing the market dominance (Pathirawasam, 2016). The division wants to produce the products at lowest possible costs and maintain excess capacity to block the potential competitors from entering the market. As the growth of the market demand is increasing, product differentiation can provide long term competitive advantage and enhance sales.

Cost structure

The cost structure of Firm A is not good due to negative productivity of the firm that increases their operating and production costs. The plant also focuses on domestic production and only has estimated the direct costs from the domestic market in their profit/loss statement that depicts lack of export promotion. However, the annual growth rate of the export market is 15% with 7% demand compared to the domestic market that has a 5% growth rate.

The cost structure is comparatively good for Firm B especially for their “Tissue Paper Division” that has a market share of 37% in South Africa. A beneficial cost structure and capital investment helps the company to maintain dominating position as well as capital expenditure proposals also motivates this division to take new decisions for product diversification. This division completed their capital expenditure planning based on three scenarios such as 5% 10% and 15% of annual growth in market demand or sales.

Capital budgeting process

Capital budgeting refers to a business process that is used to determine which proposed fixed asset purchases should be accepted and which one should be declined (Kengatharan, 2016). A quantitative view is created to determine the investment on every proposed fixed asset and judgement is made on rational basis. Firm A and Firm B both use capital budgeting tools to minimise their company profit by calculating the future accounting profit of their project. However, Firm A focuses on capital investment for relocating their plant to capture export market and minimize production costs but Firm B focuses on product diversification and maintenance of market dominance with the help of capital budgeting process.

Some processes are followed in the capital budgeting process such as,

  • Identification of investment opportunities: In this first stage, the available opportunities for investment is analysed and a sales target is set for the future. For this purpose, SWOT analysis is conducted to determine the strengths and weaknesses of a company and a corporate strategy is created based on this analysis. Firm A has identified that the company has low production rate and high cost in Polokwane plant and makes a decision to relocate the plant for export promotion and reduce costs. Firm B has completed SWOT analysis to find out the opportunity in enhancing capacity to increase sales and dominate the market.
  • Generation of proposal: A proposal is created by various authorised persons in the organisation to determine the classification of investment such as replacement, expansion, development, welfare investment and others (Fehrenbacher et al., 2020). Firm A has made a proposal for relocating their plant from Polokwane and has three options such as island location Johannesburg, coastal location Durban and foreign location Mauritius. Firm B creates capital investment proposals for capacity increment in tissue plants. The options taken by Firm B are,
  1. Rebuilding paper machine (PM) 3
  2. Upgrading the paper machine 4
  3. Renegotiate the supply contract
  4. Building of new machine
  5. Upgrading stock preparation using new technology
  6. Option E with external equipment
  7. Combining PM3 and PM4’s stock preparation
  8. Only upgrading PM4 stock preparation
  • Decision making process in capital budgeting: In this part, decisions are made after evaluating the importance, effectiveness and long-term sustainability of the new development. Firm A has made the decision that Mauritius is most effective for export promotion due to its location, absence of company taxation, low internal transport costs. It can reduce company production costs. Firm B has taken the option E to upgrade stock preparation of PM4 through technology because it can provide additional capacity to meet expected needs of tissue plant division and improve its operating efficiency (Gilbert, 2015).
  • Preparation of capital budget: In this step, higher and smaller investment values are calculated for proposals that are created by Firm A and Firm B and necessary approvals in capital budget are taken by the authorised people.
  • Implementation: The time required for the project is analysed as well as required costs and resources are evaluated. In this part, formulation of the project is completed with necessary detail. Responsibility accounting principles are utilized for cost control and specific responsibilities are divided among the project personnel to successfully complete the project on time with proposed costs. “Critical Path Method (CPM)” and “Program evaluation and review technique (PERT)” are used followed by Firm A and Firm B to implement and monitor projects.
  • Performance review

The actual result is compared with the projected result by Firm A and Firm B to determine whether the proposal is beneficial for the companies to reduce costs and maintain sustainability.

Consideration of other factors for decision making

The foreign location, Mauritius is selected to relocate their production plant from Polokwane to reduce the production costs and export sales. The other factors that are considered by Firm A to relocate their plan are access to a flexible, cheap and reliable transport network for exporting the finished goods. They also consider availability of production premises, access of staff and support infrastructure to maintain the quality standard of sisal matting (Katjiruru, 2016). This location is selected because it has lower wages, absence of company taxation, low internal transport cost that is effective for managing costs and export products directly to the European market. Other options such as Johannesburg, Port Elizabeth and Durban are not selected because it limits flexibility as well as increases cost of raw material and transport.

Although relocating to Mauritius can increase profit and reduce costs, it has potential risks because it has a new economic and cultural environment. Real Options theory is used to remove key uncertainties that are different from traditional models. However, to maintain accuracy in formal evaluation, Firm has decided to keep a production facility in Polokwane for one year and set up a pilot plant in Mauritius to remove uncertainties and improve profit.

Critical review and evaluation

Option E has been selected owing to the following reasons:

Though option F has the highest IRR, it suffered from issues of technical faults which might have affected the productivity level of the associated machinery but in case of option E it is supposed to allow PM4 to run at its original capacity. This clearly states that the IRR measures are not the most important criteria for selecting the options as there are certain factors which need to be considered for evaluation. It also possesses the ability to rectify the support system and enhance the output grading and improve the efficiency. The use of R45 instead of R15 has also been prohibited since new technology would require replacement much later. It would also supply additional abundant capacity according to the required needs of the division. It would also help in prolonging the life of the PM4 machine and thereby improve its operating efficiency for a sustained period (Gilbert, 2015). Option E also provided the ability to minimise the additional investments which have been burdening the production capacity of the present assets. Furthermore, the management found out that the IRR measures were not quantifiable as the data would have been obtained only after the pre-engineering study.


In conclusion, capital budgeting helps an organisation to determine the long term investments for purchasing or replacing the machineries, plants, products or research development through capitalisation structure of the firm. Firm A decides to relocate their production unit from Polokwane to Mauritius to improve their export promotion and reduce costs because of low wages, no taxation and low transport costs of Mauritius. Firm B takes the decision to upgrade stock preparation of PM4 with technology to develop its additional capacity and dominate the South African market.


  • The internal rate of return approach could have been used that may help in estimating the profitability of the potential investments.
  • The net present value approach can be taken under consideration by the current firm as it helps in differentiating among the present value of the cash inflows and outflows for a reasonable period of time.


Fehrenbacher, D. D., Kaplan, S. E., and Moulang, C. 2020. The role of accountability in reducing the impact of affective reactions on capital budgeting decisions. Management Accounting Research, 47, 100650.

Gilbert, E. 2015. Capital budgeting: A case study analysis of the role of formal evaluation techniques in the decision making process. South African journal of accounting Research, 19(1), 19-36.

Katjiruru, T. G. 2016. A review of capital budgeting decisions in Namibia’s state-owned entreprises (Doctoral dissertation, University of Namibia).

Kengatharan, L. 2016. Capital budgeting theory and practice: a review and agenda for future research. Applied Economics and Finance, 3(2), 15-38.

Pathirawasam, C. 2016. Capital budgeting practices: Evidence from Sri Lanka listed companies. International Journal of Management and Applied Science2(5), 23-26.

Order Now

Get solved or fresh solution on Formal Evaluation Techniques In The Decision Making Process Assignment and many more. 24X7 help, plag free solution. Order online now!

Universal Assignment (February 1, 2023) Formal Evaluation Techniques In The Decision Making Process Assignment [SOLVED]. Retrieved from
"Formal Evaluation Techniques In The Decision Making Process Assignment [SOLVED]." Universal Assignment - February 1, 2023,
Universal Assignment July 24, 2022 Formal Evaluation Techniques In The Decision Making Process Assignment [SOLVED]., viewed February 1, 2023,<>
Universal Assignment - Formal Evaluation Techniques In The Decision Making Process Assignment [SOLVED]. [Internet]. [Accessed February 1, 2023]. Available from:
"Formal Evaluation Techniques In The Decision Making Process Assignment [SOLVED]." Universal Assignment - Accessed February 1, 2023.
"Formal Evaluation Techniques In The Decision Making Process Assignment [SOLVED]." Universal Assignment [Online]. Available: [Accessed: February 1, 2023]

Please note along with our service, we will provide you with the following deliverables:

Please do not hesitate to put forward any queries regarding the service provision.

We look forward to having you on board with us.

Get 90%* Discount on Assignment Help

Most Frequent Questions & Answers

Universal Assignment Services is the best place to get help in your all kind of assignment help. We have 172+ experts available, who can help you to get HD+ grades. We also provide Free Plag report, Free Revisions,Best Price in the industry guaranteed.

We provide all kinds of assignmednt help, Report writing, Essay Writing, Dissertations, Thesis writing, Research Proposal, Research Report, Home work help, Question Answers help, Case studies, mathematical and Statistical tasks, Website development, Android application, Resume/CV writing, SOP(Statement of Purpose) Writing, Blog/Article, Poster making and so on.

We are available round the clock, 24X7, 365 days. You can appach us to our Whatsapp number +1 (613)778 8542 or email to . We provide Free revision policy, if you need and revisions to be done on the task, we will do the same for you as soon as possible.

We provide services mainly to all major institutes and Universities in Australia, Canada, China, Malaysia, India, South Africa, New Zealand, Singapore, the United Arab Emirates, the United Kingdom, and the United States.

We provide lucrative discounts from 28% to 70% as per the wordcount, Technicality, Deadline and the number of your previous assignments done with us.

After your assignment request our team will check and update you the best suitable service for you alongwith the charges for the task. After confirmation and payment team will start the work and provide the task as per the deadline.

Yes, we will provide Plagirism free task and a free turnitin report along with the task without any extra cost.

No, if the main requirement is same, you don’t have to pay any additional amount. But it there is a additional requirement, then you have to pay the balance amount in order to get the revised solution.

The Fees are as minimum as $10 per page(1 page=250 words) and in case of a big task, we provide huge discounts.

We accept all the major Credit and Debit Cards for the payment. We do accept Paypal also.

Popular Assignments

Question 10 – REPORTS

Complete the table below, by listing three types of financial reports that are produced in your workplace. Type of Report Content of Report Frequently of Report                  

Read More »


Work through the following table and indicate whether each record should be kept or destroyed. Detail the reason for your answer and how long the record should be kept (for example, legislation requirement – retain for five years). Record Keep – Yes or No Reasons Suppliers Invoices     Employee

Read More »


Using the following information, complete the Business Activity Statement, you may need to refer to the ATO website to help you complete. Download and complete the Business Activity Statement (BAS). It can be found separately on the course page.

Read More »


AVERAGE Activity 5.1 – Break-even Answers A. B.   Manage 8 Buildings Manage 10 Buildings Manage 15 Buildings Manage 20 Buildings Manage 25 Buildings Income           Less Variable Costs           Less Fixed Costs           Total Cost    

Read More »

Question 3 – Depreciation

You are the Licensee-In-Charge of Hope & Murphy Real Estate and wish to purchase computers for your new office in the CBD. Using the information below: Office fit out                      $120,000 Assets effective Life          4 years Purchase Date                  1st July STRAIGHT-LINE METHOD CALCULATION Years 1 to 4 – JOURNAL ENTRIES DEPRECIATION                                               

Read More »


Please note: Editing has been restricted in this document. From the information provided below, complete the following table: Account Name Classification Profit & Loss or Balance Sheet Amount Pay Superannuation Expense Profit & Loss $117,325 Pay Mobile Phone     $7,500 Pay Office Rent     $65,000 Land & Buildings

Read More »


Worlducation is a social startup that manufactures tablet computers for primary school students. They not only focus on the hardware, but they also have a competitive team creating software, content and activities to better engage and educate the students. Worlducation aims to change the way children learn at school by

Read More »

BSBOPS505 Manage Organisational Customer Service

BSBOPS505 MANAGE ORGANISATIONAL CUSTOMER SERVICE STUDENTASSESSMENT TASKS QIBA Pty Ltd | CRICOS Provider Code: 01515J | RTO Code: 5304 | ABN: 35 071 667 108  Student Assessment TasksBSBOPS505 Manage Organisational Customer Service     BSBOPS505 Contents Introduction  4 Assessment Task 1: Knowledge questions  5 Assessment Task 1: Checklist 9 Assessment Task 2:

Read More »


BSBOPS505 MANAGE ORGANISATIONAL CUSTOMER SERVICE STUDENT VERSION PROJECT PORTFOLIO Contents Student declaration. 3 Section 1: Establish customer service requirements. 4 Section 2: Deliver quality customer service. 9 Section 3: Monitor and assess customer service. 13 STUDENT PROJECT PORTFOLIO COVER SHEET Student declaration This declaration must be completed in full by

Read More »

GBL Final Take Home Exam

The Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) was meant to be a ground-breaking new agreement by placing 12 economies under a common set of economic norms and regulations. After the US withdrew from the TPP, the remaining 11 signatories continued talks and which led to the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans Pacific

Read More »


You will be creating a Portfolio record specifically focused on mental health assessments and pharmacological interventions. This is designed to assist in the development of theoretical and clinical skills in mental health, with a direct connection to your clinical practice as a registered student nurse. The evidence record provides you with the opportunity to showcase your learning

Read More »

NRSG375 Clinical Leadership

Assessment Task 3: Written assignment (45%) Discuss and analyse in more detail 2 of the discussion posts that you submitted for assessment task (AT) 2 and use contemporary literature for support. For the 2 posts that you choose, you are to discuss and analyse professional leadership in nursing in further

Read More »

Portfolio record specifically focused on mental health assessments

PORTFOLIO ASSESSMENT 3 You will be creating a Portfolio record specifically focused on mental health assessments and pharmacological interventions. This is designed to assist in the development of theoretical and clinical skills in mental health, with a direct connection to your clinical practice as a registered student nurse. The evidence record provides you with the opportunity to

Read More »

The aetiology of mrs simpsons pain Assignment Help

Length: 1800 words Group Assessment: No Submission method options: EASTS (online) TASK back to top This assessment task requires you to analyse the case study provided below.  In the case study,  a patient is experiencing a range of health challenges. You are required to read the case study carefully and complete the following

Read More »

The Dangers of a Single Story Assignment Help

Narrative Essay Instructions Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s TED Talk titled “The Dangers of a Single Story” recounts instances where one perspective can lead to assumptions, conclusions, and/or decisions that may incomplete or lead to misunderstandings (e.g., think about the story of Fide or how Adichie’s roommate was shocked to learn how

Read More »

LAW1101 21F – Fundamentals of Law

LAW1101 21F – Fundamentals of Law Assignment 1:  Legislative interpretation Due date: Wednesday, November 10, 2021 at 3:00pm Instructions: You are to read two excerpts from legislation and then answer questions about each of them.  The questions are weighted differently and the marks for each question are included.  There are

Read More »

A Work Based Quality Improvement Project

Project Title: Impact of educational intervention on nurses knowledge of hand hygiene in aged care setting: A Work Based Quality Improvement Project Executive Summary: (100- 150 words) Background: Hand hygiene is one of the most important strategies for preventing infections in healthcare settings and healthcare-associated infections, which affect hundreds of

Read More »

Community Health and Development

Part A :  Assessment event 3(a) details Assessment Task 3(a): Apply a problem-solving approach to a social issue in your local community by using the Community Health and Development (2017b) 10-point process. Word count: 2000 Weighting: 35% It is recommended that you: Criteria Fail <17.5 Pass 18- Credit 20 – 22 Distinction 23– 25 High Distinction 

Read More »


In this assignment, you are asked to pick ONE of the following case studies and answer a series of questions about the particular health situation that is described. In each case study, you are asked to examine the significance of the issue for Australia, explore the condition from a very broad policy

Read More »


FINAL EXAM – SPRING SESSION 2021 School of Law EXAM INSTRUCTIONS Read all the information below and follow any instructions carefully before proceeding. Clearly indicate which question you are answering.   UNIT NAME: Building Law UNIT NUMBER: 200292 NUMBER OF QUESTIONS: 4 VALUE OF QUESTIONS: Question 1 (10 marks) Question

Read More »

MGMT8055 Brief Case Writeup Bauing Construction Holding Group

Why do you think Bauing Indonesia was so successful? Suggestions government, cost, and competitive Main proof-points The first factor behind this decision was increasing competition in the building and decoration industry in China. In 2016, most public companies in this industry in China experienced decreasing gross margins due to increased

Read More »

MGMT8055 Case Writeup Xiaomi

After recognising numerous global opportunities, Xiaomi in Beijing charted its overseas market strategy in 2013. However, opportunities came with challenges, and during the internationalization process, Xiaomi encountered many problems. After three years of hard work, Xiaomi had gained more experience than profits. Compared with Xiaomi’s domestic success, Xiaomi’s internationalization strategy

Read More »

LNG11120 Developing Intercultural Competence in the Workplace

Edinburgh Napier University Academic Year 2021-22 Trimester 1 Assessment Brief 1.  Module number   LNG11120 2.  Module title   Developing Intercultural Competence in the Workplace 3.  Module leader   4.  Assessment Coursework 1: Group report – an ‘intercultural training’ plan (see Section 10 below for more details) 5.  Weighting  

Read More »

Knowledge, Individual, and Society

Essay 1 Assignment To be submitted via Turnitin on LMS. Assignment: Write a 1,200 word (not including references or footnotes) essay answering ONE of the following questions: 1) What is the Gettier problem and can we solve it? Address this question by carefully explaining and evaluating 1-2 responses to the

Read More »

9014 NPD New Product Design

Summary In the 2000-word written report, students are required to develop some specific aspects of the initial three phases of a new product (service or idea) development process. Students are expected to apply the relevant design thinking tools and ideas in this assessment. Referencing is Australian Harvard (AGPS) and outlined

Read More »

Can't Find Your Assignment?

Open chat
Free Assistance
Universal Assignment
Hello 👋
How can we help you?