Assignment 1 Written Critical Case Study Analysis

Assignment 1 Written Critical Case Study Analysis

  • Task: Students individually write a critical case study analysis. Students need to analyse and evaluate the case by applying theoretical frameworks and suggest possible ethical decision-making models.  
  • Length: 2,000 words
  • Place of Submission: Canvas

Case: Motor company

You are the Chief Communications Officer at an Australian company, Shonky Inc, that makes cars. The company is based in Hoon City, which is located in NSW. Shonky employs 50,000 of the 290,000 car industry workers in Hoon City. The car industry has been a significant contributor to Australia’s economic success.

Shonky is known for big cars, but has decided to produce a new smaller model, the Leech. The quality and performance of imported cars has improved dramatically in recent years and they have become a big threat to the Australian car industry, including to Shonky. Demand for Australian car brands has been declining, and there is concern that Shonky will not survive as a company unless it tries something new. Shonky’s employees are worried they might lose their jobs. Shonky responded by announcing it would launch the Leech in mid-2021. This meant that Shonky needed to compress its usual development time of four years into just two years.

While developing the Leech, Shonky tested various prototypes to meet a safety standard proposed by the Australian Department of Transport. The standard required all cars to have a safe petrol tank that can withstand a rear-end impact of 50kph without fuel loss. The failure to meet this standard means that there is a risk of a serious fire hazard when the car is struck from the rear. Their test results for the Leech prototypes were not satisfactory.

The company faced a decision: should they go ahead with the planned launch, thereby meeting the production timetable but possibly jeopardising consumer safety? Or should they delay production of the Leech by redesigning the gas tank to make it safer? This delay would take at least a year, which would enable foreign car companies to make further inroads into the Australian market. According to an internal report for Shonky, it was estimated that there would be fire-related deaths in 5% of all accidents involving the Leech being struck from the rear.

Financially, the Leech is likely to be a big success if it is launched on time. However, several foreign competitors are working on similar models. It is unclear when they are planning to launch them. The pressure is on to launch the Leech as soon as possible.

The Department of Transport’s proposed new safety standard is not yet compulsory. However, experts agree that the standard is a good idea, and the government has said it will make it compulsory in the future. The car industry has been lobbying the government for many years to delay the adoption of new Department of Transport crash standards. Shonky is confident that all of its tests meet the current standards.

If Shonky can produce the Leech as planned, sales are expected to be up by $137.5 million dollars per year. In addition, it would keep its workers employed in the auto industry. If not, there are likely to be significant job losses, though the extent of these job losses is hard to predict.

Questions:

As a CCO, you need to advise your top management to help them make a decision regarding a production plan of the Leech based on an ethical framework and devise your communications strategy that supports the decision.

Your answer should be structured as follows:

1. Introduction – an outline of your argument. (100 words)

2. What are the key facts, what are the key ethical issues at stake, and who are the key stakeholders? (200 words)

3. Apply a deontological framework. What are the pros and cons of this approach? (400 words)

4. Apply a consequentialist framework. What are the pros and cons of this approach? (400 words)

5. Apply a relativist framework. What are the pros and cons of this approach? (250 words)

6. Devise three different communication messages, one that aligns with your deontological analysis, one for your consequentialist analysis, and one for your relativist analysis. (350 words).

7. Based on your answers from 2 to 6, what is your conclusion for our two big questions: Should Y go ahead with their plan, thereby meeting the original launch timetable? Or should they delay production of a new car model Leech?

In your response, please specifywhich ethical framework(s) you rely on to reach your two answers (Note: Your conclusion can also include references to virtue ethics, situationism and other ethical frameworks/ethical decision-making models from our reading list and beyond, but this is not compulsory) (300 words)

NB: There is no single right answer. Your answer will be marked mainly on the reasoning you use to get to your conclusions, not on the specific conclusions themselves.

Order Now
No Fields Found.
Universal Assignment (June 24, 2025) Assignment 1 Written Critical Case Study Analysis. Retrieved from https://universalassignment.com/assignment-1-written-critical-case-study-analysis/.
"Assignment 1 Written Critical Case Study Analysis." Universal Assignment - June 24, 2025, https://universalassignment.com/assignment-1-written-critical-case-study-analysis/
Universal Assignment July 6, 2022 Assignment 1 Written Critical Case Study Analysis., viewed June 24, 2025,<https://universalassignment.com/assignment-1-written-critical-case-study-analysis/>
Universal Assignment - Assignment 1 Written Critical Case Study Analysis. [Internet]. [Accessed June 24, 2025]. Available from: https://universalassignment.com/assignment-1-written-critical-case-study-analysis/
"Assignment 1 Written Critical Case Study Analysis." Universal Assignment - Accessed June 24, 2025. https://universalassignment.com/assignment-1-written-critical-case-study-analysis/
"Assignment 1 Written Critical Case Study Analysis." Universal Assignment [Online]. Available: https://universalassignment.com/assignment-1-written-critical-case-study-analysis/. [Accessed: June 24, 2025]

Please note along with our service, we will provide you with the following deliverables:

Please do not hesitate to put forward any queries regarding the service provision.

We look forward to having you on board with us.

Most Frequent Questions & Answers

Universal Assignment Services is the best place to get help in your all kind of assignment help. We have 172+ experts available, who can help you to get HD+ grades. We also provide Free Plag report, Free Revisions,Best Price in the industry guaranteed.

We provide all kinds of assignmednt help, Report writing, Essay Writing, Dissertations, Thesis writing, Research Proposal, Research Report, Home work help, Question Answers help, Case studies, mathematical and Statistical tasks, Website development, Android application, Resume/CV writing, SOP(Statement of Purpose) Writing, Blog/Article, Poster making and so on.

We are available round the clock, 24X7, 365 days. You can appach us to our Whatsapp number +1 (613)778 8542 or email to info@universalassignment.com . We provide Free revision policy, if you need and revisions to be done on the task, we will do the same for you as soon as possible.

We provide services mainly to all major institutes and Universities in Australia, Canada, China, Malaysia, India, South Africa, New Zealand, Singapore, the United Arab Emirates, the United Kingdom, and the United States.

We provide lucrative discounts from 28% to 70% as per the wordcount, Technicality, Deadline and the number of your previous assignments done with us.

After your assignment request our team will check and update you the best suitable service for you alongwith the charges for the task. After confirmation and payment team will start the work and provide the task as per the deadline.

Yes, we will provide Plagirism free task and a free turnitin report along with the task without any extra cost.

No, if the main requirement is same, you don’t have to pay any additional amount. But it there is a additional requirement, then you have to pay the balance amount in order to get the revised solution.

The Fees are as minimum as $10 per page(1 page=250 words) and in case of a big task, we provide huge discounts.

We accept all the major Credit and Debit Cards for the payment. We do accept Paypal also.

Popular Assignments

Nursing Ethics and Law – Henry Pearson Case Study

Nursing Ethics and Law – Henry Pearson Case Study Course Code & NameNUR1103 |Context of Professional PracticeAssessment Item and NameAssessment THREE | Case StudyAssessment Item TypeEssay/ Case studyDue Date & TimeWeek 10 | 15th March 23:59 hrsLengthEssay is 1200 words + or – 10%Marks and WeightingOverall mark is out of

Read More »

NUR3397 – Complex Care Case Study Presentation

Course Code & NameNUR3397 |Complex Care AAssessment Item and NameAssessment TWO | PresentationAssessment Item TypeIndividual oral presentationDue Date & TimeWeek 10 | 22nd April 23:59 hrsResults data will be returned to you three weeks after your submission dateLength12-15 minute oral presentation recorded to ZOOM cloud + or – 10%Marks and

Read More »

AI in Recruitment: Legal and Ethical Implications for Harmony Haven

PurposeThis assessment helps you demonstrate report-writing skills essential for HR and other professional roles. It develops your research abilities, including sourcing, reviewing, and synthesizing academic and non-academic literature. Strong report-writing skills support informed business decisions, enhancing your ability to assist managers and advance your career. AI in Recruitment: Legal and

Read More »

Youth Justice Crisis: Indigenous Incarceration in Australia

issues During Impact Root  cause Youth justice crisis ongoing Disproportionate indigenous youth incarcerations reports of abuse eg Don Dale Low age of criminal responsibility (10) – Systemic racism and overpolicing – Lack of diversion and rehabilitation pathways Word: 1000 Topic selected: Youth Justic Crisis, Assessment 1: Conflict Analysis Exercise –

Read More »

PV System Design and Energy Analysis for Residential Use

Executive Summary Provide a brief summary of the key methods and key results, max 500 words. 1.         Introduction (aims and objectives and brief description of the system studied and methods of the next sections) approximately half a page 2.         Solar irradiation analysis Provide location and data used. Provide hourly GHI,

Read More »

Assignment 3: Statistical Analysis and Recommendations for Enhancing HDI

Student Name:               Your full name Student ID:                     Your Student ID Make sure to delete the instructions!! Introduction: Include a succinct introduction at the start of your report. You may write a few sentences about purpose of this report, the type of analysis, or any other relevant information (about 50 words).

Read More »

Brian Old Age Case study Assignment

Assessment 1 – Written AssessmentAssessment TypePurposeDescriptionWritten AssignmentThe purpose of this assessment is to broaden each student’s understanding of the modulecontent using a case study and assessment toolsCase Study: Brian is an 84-year-old retired farmer in a rural area in Northern Territory. Hewas recently assessed following a minor motor vehicle accident

Read More »

Assessment name: Portfolio of planning cycle

Assessment name: Portfolio of planning cycleDue Date: Friday 13 June 11:59pmWeighting: 50%Length: 2000 wordsTask Description: This Portfolio is comprised of two tasks. You must submit your assessment as onedocument. Task 1: Anecdotal record and learning experienceAnecdotal recordView the video of pre-schoolers provided under the link “Video for Assessment 2” andcomplete

Read More »

NUR5327 Assessment 3 Assignment Help

Name NUR5327 Assessment 3 (Essay)Purpose The purpose of this assessment is to demonstrate your understanding of therolesof leadership and management in healthcare by identifying and analysinga change you have actively participated in, and how it relates to key topicssuch as interprofessional communication, evidence-based practice, and staffdevelopment.LearningOutcomes NUR5327 Assessment 3 Assignment

Read More »

Mathematics Investigation and Reflection Assignment Help

Submission: Mathematics Investigation and Reflection Assignment Help TurnitinFormat:Individual written document.Uses the current APA referencing style correctly.Length:2,000 wordsThreshold Detail:For this assessment task you must obtain at least 50% of the overall result (i.e. 25 points). If the total result for this unit is at least 50 points but you scored less

Read More »

FASS Research Proposal Template Assignment

FASS Research Proposal Template Word length2000 to 3000 wordsTitleUse a concise and descriptive title that accurately reflects the content of the proposal.Background context and significanceThis section should explain the background and context of the proposed research work,indicating the main contribution to knowledge you wish to make.Aims and objectivesInclude a clear

Read More »

Evidence to Inform Nursing Practice Assignment Help

Unit Code:   NURS12165 Unit Title:    Evidence to Inform Nursing Practice Assessment Three Type:                               Written Assessment Due date:                         Week 11: Wednesday, 28 May 2025 at 1600 (AEST) Extensions:                     Available as per policy Return date:                    Results for this assessment will be made available on Wednesday, 18 June 2025 Weighting:                       50% Length:                           

Read More »

NUR1120 | Burden of Disease and Health Equity

Assessment Item Task SheetCourse code andnameNUR1120 | Burden of Disease and Health Equity Assessment itemand nameAssessment Three | ReportDue date and time Week 11 | 22/04/2025 at 2359 hours AESTLength 1400 words (+/- 10% in each section) – includes in-text references, but not reference list.Marks out of:Weighting:80 Marks50%Assessed CourseLearning Outcomes(CLO)CLO1,

Read More »

PSY1040 Portfolio: Cultural Responsiveness & Self-Awareness

Course Code and NamePSY1040: An Introduction to Cultural Safety in PracticeAssessment Item Number and NameAssessment 2: PortfolioAssessment Item TypePortfolio PSY1040 Portfolio: Cultural Responsiveness & Self-AwarenessDue Date & TimeTuesday, 29 April 2025 (Week 12), 11:59pmLength2000 words – an average of 400 words per task.Marks and WeightingMarked out of: 100Weighting: 50%Assessed Course

Read More »

Innovative Digital App Development Report

OVERALL DESCRIPTION OF TYPE OF ASSIGNMENT Assessment 1- Type of Assignment Individual Written Report Details Individual Written Report 3,000 words (500 words of the Report is Contextualisation) Weighting of Assessment : 70% INDIVIDUAL MARK Learning outcomes assessed by Assessment: 1, 2, 3 and 4 – See Module Listings of Learning

Read More »

Tourism Trends and Investment Decisions: A Comparative Study

Assignment TaskYou are a strategist working for a major hospitality group based in Australia. The company is planninginternational expansion, and the board has asked you to compile a report to identify the most suitablelocation for the project. The board has shortlisted two international locations (which will be allocatedto you by

Read More »

EC502 Language and Literacy in the Early Years

EC502 Language and Literacy in the Early Years Unit Code/Description EC502 Language and Literacy in the Early Years Course/Subject Bachelor of Early Childhood Education Semester March 2025 Assessment Overview   Unit Learning Outcomes Addressed 1, 2, 3 Assessment Objective Assessment 1: Poster Including an Invigilated stage in Week 3. Due

Read More »

EC501 Early Childhood Learning and Development

Unit Code/Description EC501 Early Childhood Learning and Development Course/Subject Graduate Diploma in Education (early childhood) Semester S 1, 2025 Assessment Overview   Unit Learning Outcomes Addressed 1, 2, 3 Assessment Objective In this assessment, student are required to select one of the case studies provided and critically analyze the child’s

Read More »

JSB172: Professional Academic Skills

JSB172: Professional Academic SkillsAssessment: Workplace Report and Presentation Weight: 50%Due date: Friday 30th May 11:59pm Length: 1,750 words (+/- 10 %) / 5minutesPurpose/Learning Objectives:This assessment relates to Learning Outcomes 1, 2, 3, and 4: Task:Your task is to write a Workplace Report identifying how to address the topic/issue chosen or

Read More »

2015PSY Developmental Psychology Assignment

2015PSY Developmental Psychology Assignment 2025 2015PSY Developmental Psychology Assignment Assignment MaterialsAssignment Information Sheet & Marking Criteria.pdf (this document)Assignment Template.docx (template)Example Assignment.pdf (HD exemplar)Due Date: Friday 16 May, 11:59PM (Week 10)Weighting: Marked out of 100 (worth 30% of course grade)Word Count: 1,500 words maximum(inclusive of main text, headings, in-text citations; excluding

Read More »

Principles of Economics Federal Budget

Principles of Economics Short-answer Assignment V1 (20% of final mark) The assignment consists of four questions.  You should allocate at least half a page (or 250 words) to each answer or 1000 words for all four answers depending on the nature of and/or marks allocated for the question/s. You may

Read More »

LML6003 – AUSTRALIA’S VISA SYSTEM 1 (FAMILY AND OTHERVISAS)

Graduate Diploma in Migration Law LML6003 – AUSTRALIA’S VISA SYSTEM 1 (FAMILY AND OTHER VISAS) Assessment Task 2 – Semester 1, 2025 LML6003 – AUSTRALIA’S VISA SYSTEM 1 (FAMILY AND OTHERVISAS) Instructions: 1. Students must answer all questions as indicated. Make certain all answers are clearly labelled. 2. Make certain

Read More »

Construction Cadetships in the Australian Construction Industry

REPORT TOPICPrepare an Academic Report on the following:‘Construction Cadetships in the Australian Construction Industry’.The report should encompass the following: Your personal evaluation and critique of the key findings in your report including your evaluation of construction cadetships, yourfindings in relation to potential issues/problems with cadetships and your recommendations to improve

Read More »

Assessing Corporate Governance and its Significance

Assessing Corporate Governance and its Significance: A Case Study Analysis Overview: Accounting irregularities have cost investors millions of dollars and, most importantly, adversely impacted their confidence in the financial system. While there have been remarkable improvements in regulatory supervision, auditing framework and reporting transparency, young graduates must assess major corporate

Read More »

Master of Professional Accounting and Accounting Advanced

Assessment 2 – Business Case (CVP) AnalysisUnit Code/Description ACC901 Accounting for Managerial DecisionsCourse/Subject Master of Professional Accounting and Master of Professional Accounting AdvancedSemester S1 2025 Assessment Overview Unit Learning OutcomesAddressed1,2,3,4 and 5Assessment Objective The primary objective of this assessment is to assess the students’ ability to apply CVPanalysis and relevant

Read More »

Urban Design Theory Essay writing

Essays are a major form of assessment at university. Through essays, you develop your understanding of discipline-specific content, strengthen your critical thinking, and develop your ability to translate that thinking into a persuasive written form. This assignment assesses your understanding of the following Unit Learning Outcomes: 1) understand the historic

Read More »

Statutory Interpretation of Disability Discrimination in NSW Law

Foundations of Law 70102 – Assessment Task 3 – Autumn 2025Statutory Interpretation and Research ExerciseDue: Thursday 22 May 2025 by 23.59Length: 2000 words (excluding the headings Part A, Part B and Part C, footnotes andbibliography. Any additional headings that you decide to use will be included in the wordcount)Weighting: 40%Task

Read More »

Can't Find Your Assignment?